Orville Redenbacher vs. Act II vs. Pop Secret vs. Pop Weaver: Who is Best for Microwave Popcorn?

What are the most popular popcorns?

Some of the most popular popcorns on the market include:

1. Orville Redenbacher

2. Act II

3. Pop Secret

4. Pop Weaver

Choosing the best popcorn brand truly hinges on one's personal preference. Are you eager to discover the specific distinctions that set each type of popcorn apart?

My team of ten and I embarked on an absolutely thrilling and painstaking adventure as we sampled these highly renowned popcorn varieties. 

Each member brought their discerning palate and diverse perspectives to the table, ensuring a truly comprehensive assessment. 

I will carefully select the four most representative reviews from different individuals with unique experiences to share with you all.

The 4 best popcorns

#1. What is Orville Redenbacher?

Orville Redenbacher is a well-known brand of popcorn. Renowned for its quality and variety of flavors, it offers products like Movie Theater Butter Microwave Popcorn. The brand is associated with Orville Redenbacher himself, a pioneer in popcorn.

Orville Redenbacher's Movie Theater Butter Microwave Popcorn

($6.68, 3.29 oz, 12 Count FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($7.99, 3.29 oz, 12 Count FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

#2. What is Act II?

Act II is also a brand of popcorn. Known for its movie theater-style popcorn taste, it offers a relatively mild butter flavor compared to some other brands. 

Act II Butter Lovers Microwave Popcorn

($5.53, 2.75 oz, 12 Count FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($6.49, 2.75 oz, 12 Count FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

#3. What is Pop Secret?

Pop Secret is a popular brand of microwave popcorn.

Pop Secret® Microwave Popcorn Movie Theater Butter Flavor

($6.18, 3.2 oz, 12 Count FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($10.99, 3.2 oz, 12 Count FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

#4. What is Pop Weaver?

Pop Weaver is a popcorn brand that offers flavors like Extra Butter and Kettle Corn. 

Pop Weaver Extra Butter Microwave Popcorn

($4.45, 12 Count FROM H‑E‑B  - Get Up To 0% Cash Back)

A quick look at the differences between 4 well-known snacks

Each brand has its own unique characteristics, from flavor and texture to packaging and price. Let's dive in and see how they stack up.

Editor's review: Orville Redenbacher vs. Act II vs. Pop Secret vs. Pop Weaver: Which one is best?

My number one choice is Orville Redenbacher's Microwave Popcorn!

($6.68, 3.29 oz, 12 Count FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($7.99, 3.29 oz, 12 Count FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

❤️ There are so many reasons why Orville Redenbacher's Movie Theater Butter Microwave Popcorn is my absolute favorite. 

For one, that rich and indulgent buttery flavor is just like the popcorn you get at the movies, and it brings back all those great memories of fun cinema trips and cozy movie nights at home. 

The fact that it uses whole grain popping corn is a bonus for me because it gives me a slightly healthier option while still being delicious. 

The brand's reputation for quality and consistency is also a big deal. Knowing that I'm getting a product that's likely to pop well and have few unpopped kernels just makes it even better. 

The texture is another thing I love. Those large, fluffy kernels with a nice crispness are so satisfying to eat. 

Or maybe it's because of the variety of other flavors the brand offers. Knowing I can switch it up when I want to, but always come back to that classic movie theater butter flavor is great. 

And finally, the convenience of being able to quickly and easily make a delicious snack in the microwave whenever I have a craving is just awesome.

Its large package size is also perfect for sharing with friends and family, making it a great choice for parties and casual times.

Money Saving Tips First:

In fact, you can save up to 100% on online shopping at home and abroad! 

Such a high amount of cash back comes from Extrabux (What is Extrabux?), it also offers coupon codes and recent promotions, and brings together 10,000+ sites (US, China, UK, Japan, Australia , Germany, France, Italy, etc.).

Just sign up for an Extrabux account and earn exciting cash back every time you place an order via the relevant link. Sign-Up Bonus: Join for FREE & Earn $20 Welcome Bonus today! Then earn $5 Friend Referral Bonus!

Whether you are buying cheap domestic products, international luxury goods, or buying mobile phones, computers, refrigerators, washing machines, clothes, shoes, bags, mother and baby products, snacks, drinks, or booking air tickets, hotels, car rentals, or registering services and memberships , you can save money on all related purchases - save $1,000 a year!

MORE FROM

Top 10 Strongest Mints in the World 2024

Love the taste of mint? Here are some...

45737

Details

Real Reviews and Comparisons of the Best popcorns

As a popcorn tester, I embarked on a journey to determine which of these four popular microwave popcorn brands reigns supreme. 

#1. Orville Redenbacher vs. Pop Secret vs. Act II vs. Pop Weaver: Taste

►  Orville Redenbacher:

Buttery taste: Has a buttery taste, although not overly intense. Some say this popcorn has a smooth, evenly distributed buttery flavor. 

Flavor balance: Tends to have a good balance between the buttery flavor and the natural taste of the popcorn. The added natural flavor (including milk) gives it a distinct flavor profile.

Artificial taste: Generally not considered to have an artificial taste. However, some tasters might find the "fake butter taste" slightly sweet.

Flavor selection: Offers a variety of flavors including movie theater butter. Known for its consistent quality in flavor.

►  Pop Secret:

Buttery taste: The buttery flavor is not as pronounced as some other brands. Some say this popcorn has a buttery flavor and salty deliciousness.

Flavor balance: May have a slightly off balance as some tasters find it has a powdery and artificial flavor. The addition of rosemary extract, annatto and paprika extracts for color, and lactic acid might contribute to this unique but not always pleasing flavor balance.

Artificial taste: Often criticized for having a forgettable, powdery, artificial flavor.

Flavor selection: Offers movie theater butter flavor along with other varieties.

►  Act II:

Buttery taste: Lacks a strong buttery taste.

Flavor balance: Fairly standard flavor without being overly buttery or salty. 

Artificial taste: Not typically described as having an artificial taste, but also not highly praised for its flavor.

Flavor selection: Focuses on a more basic flavor experience.

►  Pop Weaver:

Buttery taste: Has a great flavor but the butter flavor is underwhelming.

Flavor balance: Some reviewers appreciate the lack of an overly artificial butter flavor compared to other brands. Some say this popcorn mainly tastes salty, but not buttery. 

Artificial taste: Generally not considered to have an artificial taste.

Flavor selection: May have unique flavor varieties but is less widely reviewed in terms of flavor selection compared to the other brands.

#2. Orville Redenbacher vs. Pop Secret vs. Act II vs. Pop Weaver: Texture

►  Orville Redenbacher:

Kernel size: Large, fluffy kernels with a noticeable "pillowy" texture.

Popping consistency: Generally good popping consistency with few unpopped kernels. Orville Redenbacher's popcorn is light and fluffy, with a 44:1 ratio of popped to unpopped kernels.

Crispness: Has a pleasant crispness without being overly hard.

Moisture content: Not overly moist or dry. The popcorn has a balanced moisture level that contributes to its overall texture. This popcorn has a light and fluffy texture with a crispy exterior and tender interior. 

►  Pop Secret:

Kernel size: Slightly smaller, evenly popped kernels with a good crunch.

Popping consistency: Known for its consistent popping, but may have a higher rate of unpopped kernels in some cases.

Crispness: Offers a good level of crispness.

Moisture content: Tends to have a relatively balanced moisture level, not too dry or soggy.

►  Act II:

Kernel size: Consistent, medium-sized kernels.

Popping consistency: Fairly standard popping consistency.

Crispness: Has a crisp crunch. However, it can sometimes be described as chewy and stale like movie theater popcorn.

Moisture content: May have a tendency to be drier or less moist compared to some other brands.

►  Pop Weaver:

Kernel size: Some customers like the quality of Pop Weaver popcorn, which they say has large, buttery kernels. 

Popping consistency: Reviews suggest that it may not pop as full as other brands.

Crispness: Varies depending on the batch but can be crisp.

Moisture content: Generally, it may have a slightly lighter texture compared to Orville Redenbacher.

#3. Orville Redenbacher vs. Pop Secret vs. Act II vs. Pop Weaver: Ingredients and Nutrition

►  Biggest Differences in Ingredient Lists:

Orville Redenbacher's use of whole grain popping corn is a huge draw for me. I'm always on the lookout for snacks that offer more fiber and nutrients, and this definitely ticks that box. The mixed tocopherols in it are a great bonus too, as they help keep the popcorn fresh for longer.

Now, when it comes to Pop Secret, that paprika extract really sets it apart. It not only gives the popcorn a different color but also imparts a potentially unique flavor profile. The lactic acid in it can definitely have an impact on both taste and preservation. However, I can see how some people might be a bit hesitant due to the taste associated with these ingredients.

Act II's use of TBHQ and citric acid for freshness is a bit of a double-edged sword. While it's great that they're trying to keep the popcorn fresh, there are concerns for some consumers about the potential health implications of these preservatives. 

As for Pop Weaver, the addition of butter is a game-changer. It gives the popcorn a real butter flavor that I absolutely love. But for those with soy allergies, the presence of soy ingredients can be a major concern. 

►  Calories:

When it comes to calories, Pop Weaver really packs a punch with 300 calories per serving. That's a lot compared to Orville Redenbacher's 170 calories, Act II's 140 calories, and Pop Secret's 130 calories. 

If you're watching your calorie intake, Pop Secret or Act II might be the way to go. But if you need more energy or aren't too worried about calories, Pop Weaver could be a good choice.

►  Total Fat and Saturated Fat:

Now, looking at total fat and saturated fat, Pop Weaver takes the lead again with 17 grams of total fat and 8 grams of saturated fat. Orville Redenbacher has 11 grams of total fat and 6 grams of saturated fat. Pop Secret has 8 grams of total fat and 4 grams of saturated fat, and Act II has 7 grams of total fat and 3 grams of saturated fat. 

We all know that too much saturated fat can increase the risk of heart disease, so if you're concerned about your heart health, Pop Secret or Act II might be a better bet than Pop Weaver or Orville Redenbacher.

►  Sodium:

Moving on to sodium, Pop Weaver once again has the highest content at 760 milligrams. Orville Redenbacher has 340 milligrams, Act II has 310 milligrams, and Pop Secret has 270 milligrams. 

Excessive sodium intake can lead to high blood pressure and other health problems, so if you're keeping an eye on your sodium intake, Pop Secret is probably your best option.

►  Total Carbohydrate and Dietary Fiber:

When it comes to total carbohydrates and dietary fiber, Pop Weaver has the highest total carbohydrate count at 34 grams and the highest dietary fiber at 5 grams. Act II has 20 grams of total carbohydrates and 3 grams of dietary fiber. Orville Redenbacher has 17 grams of total carbohydrates and 3 grams of dietary fiber, while Pop Secret has 12 grams of total carbohydrates and 2 grams of dietary fiber. 

Higher dietary fiber can be great for digestive health and can help you feel full. So if you're looking for more fiber, Pop Weaver might be your pick. But if you're watching your carbohydrate intake, Pop Secret could be a better choice.

►  Protein:

Finally, in terms of protein, Pop Weaver has the highest content at 4 grams. Orville Redenbacher, Pop Secret, and Act II all have 2 grams of protein. If you're looking to increase your protein intake, Pop Weaver could be a good option. However, the difference in protein content among the brands is relatively small.

In conclusion, when choosing between these popcorn brands, it's important to consider your nutritional needs and preferences. 

#4. Orville Redenbacher vs. Pop Secret vs. Act II vs. Pop Weaver: Packaging

►  Design:

When it comes to Orville Redenbacher, the packaging design might not be the most distinctive out there, but it does offer some handy convenience features. The bag is relatively easy to open, which is a big plus for me.

Pop Secret's packaging seems to be designed with easy opening and handling in mind. Plus, it might have some visual appeal that really catches your eye on store shelves.

As for Act II, unfortunately, there aren't any specific details about unique design or convenience features. It presumably has standard packaging that's functional but not really standout in terms of design or convenience.

Pop Weaver also doesn't have any particular design or convenience features that set it apart.

►  Sizes:

Orville Redenbacher has a serving size of 2 tbsp (35g) unpopped, which makes about 5.5 cups popped. 

Pop Secret comes in a 3 oz sharing bag with 12 count in a package. Although it's not exactly clear how this translates to portion size, it's likely similar to Orville Redenbacher in terms of the number of servings per package. 

Act II has a serving size of 2 tbsp (32g) unpopped, making about 4.5 cups popped. 

And Pop Weaver? Well, there aren't specific portion size details other than the fact that the bags seem oversized and are only about 75% full after cooking. 

#5. Orville Redenbacher vs. Pop Secret vs. Act II vs. Pop Weaver: Price

Orville Redenbacher comes in at a range of $6.68 to $7.99 for a 3.29 oz, 12-count package. Pop Secret ranges from $6.18 to $10.99 for a 3.2 oz, 12-count package. Act II is a more budget-friendly option, priced at $5.53 to $6.49 for a 2.75 oz, 12-count package. And then there's Pop Weaver, which is $4.45 for a 12-count package from H-E-B. However, it's hard to find in the market.

If you're on a tight budget, Act II and Pop Weaver are definitely more affordable choices. On the other hand, Orville Redenbacher and Pop Secret might be worth the higher price for those who really value specific ingredients or nutritional profiles. 

#6. Orville Redenbacher vs. Pop Secret vs. Act II vs. Pop Weaver: real user reviews

►  Orville Redenbacher Reviews:

"Orville Redenbacher's movie theater butter popcorn is hands down my favorite. The buttery flavor is just right, not too overpowering. The kernels pop nicely and there are hardly any unpopped ones."

"I love that Orville Redenbacher uses whole grain popping corn. It makes me feel a bit better about indulging in popcorn. The taste is always consistent and delicious."

"The packaging of Orville Redenbacher is convenient and easy to open. The popcorn itself has a great texture and that classic buttery goodness."

"I've tried a lot of popcorn brands, but Orville Redenbacher always stands out. The flavor is rich and it's perfect for movie nights at home."

"The price is a bit higher than some other brands, but it's worth it for the quality. Orville Redenbacher's popcorn is a must-have in our household."

"I really appreciate the variety of flavors Orville Redenbacher offers. The movie theater butter is my go-to, but I also like to try the others from time to time."

"The texture of Orville Redenbacher's popcorn is fluffy and light. The buttery taste lingers in a good way. Highly recommend!"

►  Pop Secret Reviews:

"Pop Secret is a reliable brand. The movie theater butter flavor is pretty good, although not as intense as I'd like it to be sometimes."

"I like the fact that Pop Secret is widely available. The popcorn pops well and the taste is decent for a quick snack."

"The packaging of Pop Secret is eye-catching. The flavor is okay, but it does have a bit of an artificial taste at times."

"Pop Secret is a good option when you're on a budget. It's not the best popcorn out there, but it gets the job done."

"I've had some batches of Pop Secret with a lot of unpopped kernels, but overall it's still a decent brand."

"The light butter flavor of Pop Secret is a good choice if you're watching your calorie intake. Not too heavy on the butter."

"Pop Secret is a middle-of-the-road popcorn brand. It's not amazing, but it's not bad either. Good for an occasional snack."

►  Act II Reviews:

"Act II popcorn is a good basic option. It doesn't have a super strong flavor, but it's still enjoyable."

"I find Act II to be a great value for the price. The popcorn is consistent and has a nice crunch."

"The packaging of Act II is simple and functional. The popcorn itself is fine, not extraordinary but not bad either."

"Act II is a good choice if you want something that's not too buttery or salty. It's a more neutral flavor."

"I've had some issues with unpopped kernels with Act II, but the taste is okay for a quick snack."

"The texture of Act II popcorn is good. It's not as fluffy as some other brands, but it has a nice crispness."

"Act II is a reliable brand when you're looking for an affordable popcorn option. Nothing fancy, but it does the job."

►  Pop Weaver Reviews:

"Pop Weaver has a unique flavor that I really enjoy. The butter flavor is not too strong, but it's still good."

"I like that Pop Weaver uses natural ingredients. The popcorn has a clean taste and is a nice change from other brands."

"The packaging of Pop Weaver is nice. The popcorn pops well and has a good texture."

"Pop Weaver is a bit hard to find, but when I do find it, I always grab a bag. It's a great popcorn option."

"The price of Pop Weaver is reasonable considering the quality. I like the added bonus of it being made with non-GMO kernels."

"Pop Weaver's flavor selection is not as extensive as some other brands, but what they do offer is delicious."

"I've had some really good batches of Pop Weaver popcorn. It's a brand that I'll keep looking for when I'm in the mood for something different."

#7. Orville Redenbacher vs. Pop Secret vs. Act II vs. Pop Weaver: Conclusion

Each brand has its pros and cons. Orville Redenbacher is a classic choice with a good balance of flavor and quality, but it comes at a higher price. Pop Secret is widely available but may not satisfy those looking for a natural taste. Act II is an affordable option but lacks a standout flavor. Pop Weaver has some unique qualities but is limited in availability.

Ultimately, the best brand depends on your personal preferences. If you're watching your calorie, fat, or sodium intake, Pop Secret or Act II might be a better choice. If you prefer a stronger buttery flavor and don't mind paying a bit more, Orville Redenbacher could be for you. And if you're looking for something different and don't mind searching for it, Pop Weaver might be worth a try.

Final Verdict: Orville Redenbacher vs. Act II vs. Pop Secret vs. Pop Weaver: Which one is best?

My number one choice is Orville Redenbacher's Microwave Popcorn!

($6.68, 3.29 oz, 12 Count FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($7.99, 3.29 oz, 12 Count FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

❤️ I love Orville Redenbacher's popcorn for its unique flavors, satisfying texture, use of real ingredients, and suitability for sharing.

More：

Extrabux is an international cashback shopping site, offering up to 30% cashback from 10,000+ Stores!

Squarespace, SkinStore, MATCHESFASHION, The Wall Street Journal, NordVPN, Visible, Armani Exchange, Sam's Club, PUMA, AliExpress, Card Cash, NET-A-PORTER, Udacity, Udemy, Selfridges, LOOKFANTASTIC, Vimeo, Coach Outlet, lululemon, PrettyLittleThing, Booking.com, Ripley's Aquarium, iHerb, Groupon, etc.

Join to get $20 welcome bonus now! (How does Welcome Bonus work?)