It contains affiliate links and Extrabux will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on Extrabux links.

3

Fairlife vs. Lactaid vs. Horizon vs. Organic Valley: Which Milk Brand is the Best?

Fairlife vs. Lactaid vs. Horizon vs. Organic Valley: Which Milk Brand is the Best?

    A healthy diet, essential for overall well-being, is easier than you think by simply including three servings of dairy daily, including delicious and nutritious milk. Milk is a great source of vitamins and nutrients, and it has several health benefits, such as: boosts immune system, improve bones and teeth health, rebuild muscles, lose weight, etc. Anyone that has been looking for the best milk brand might have heard of Fairlife, Lactaid, Horizon, and Organic Valley. Which milk brand is the best? Which one is best for you? Who wins the milk brand showdown? Therefore in this Fairlife vs. Lactaid vs. Horizon vs. Organic Valley comparison, we want to look at these four milk brands from top to bottom. This includes their history, ingredients, nutrition, price, pros & cons, farms, flavors, types of milk, and more!

Cover Photo:freepik.com freepik

Fairlife vs. Lactaid vs. Horizon vs. Organic Valley


FairlifeLactaid
HorizonOrganic Valley
PriceFrom $4.38From $2.99From $4.74From $4.96
Founded in 2012197420051988
Feature
  • Ultra-Filtered

  • Fresh Milk

  • Lactose-Free

  • Non GMO 

  • USDA Organic

  • B Corporation 

    Certified

  • Non GMO 

  • USDA Organic 

  • Grass-Fed

Per Serving
Protein13, 23g8g, 13g8g5g, 8g
Sugar6, 10, 12, 21g11, 12, 24g12, 21, 22, 23g11, 12, 17, 21g
Calcium380mg, 680mg300, 310, 430, 500mg290, 300, 320, 330mg160, 270, 280, 290, 310mg



Flavors

OriginalOriginalOriginalOriginal
Strawberry MilkChocolate MilkChocolate MilkChocolate Milk
Chocolate Milk
Strawberry Milk


Vanilla Milk
Size14oz, 52oz32oz, 52 oz, 64oz, 96oz8oz, 59oz, 64oz8oz, 32oz, 64oz 

Fairlife Reviews

Fairlife began in 2012 with the belief that milk and its natural health benefits can be used to create great tasting products that nourish consumers and fit into their modern lifestyles. They specialize in delicious, dairy-based products to give everyone the nutrition they need. They are proud to provide nourishment and vitality to the world through a wide range of better-for-you products. Including:

1. fairlife ultra-filtered milk

50% more protein and 50% less sugar than regular milk

2. Core Power

high-quality protein shakes to help build lean muscle and support workout recovery

3. fairlife Nutrition Plan

high-protein nutrition shakes

image.png

Source:fairlife.com

Pros & Cons

Pros Cons
  • Fairlife traces their milk from farm to bottle, so they work with supplying dairies that are able to deliver milk that meets their high standards.
  • No Lactose-free milk.

  • Fresh milk tastes better. That's a fact. It's the reason why they take great care of their milk and quick-chilI it down to 37°, keeping it cool all the way to your local store. That's why their milk always tastes so fresh.


  • Less sugar, more proteln and more calcium. They flow their milk through special soft filters to concentrate the protein and calcium and filter out most of the sugar.


  • 4 milks are lactose-free. 


Lactaid Reviews

Lactaid was founded by Alan E. Kligerman, a third-generation dairyman who got his start in the business of delivering milk to customers in Atlantic City. During his routes, Alan discovered that not everyone could enjoy his family’s delicious products due to lactose. So, Alan studied dairy science at Cornell and after graduating, founded Lactaid in 1974. At long last, those sensitive to the lactose in dairy had a delicious solution. Lactaid breaks down the lactose from farm-fresh dairy milk using a natural lactase enzyme. 100% real dairy milk, just without the discomfort. Which means delicious dairy enjoyment for all.

  • Lactaid is 100% real milk, just without the lactose. So you can enjoy it even if you’re sensitive.

  • It’s not just delicious, it’s easy to digest. So it has all the goodness of real milk with none of the discomfort.

image.png

Source:lactaid.com

Pros & Cons

Pros Cons
  • Lactaid is farm-fresh milk from cows.

  • Less flavor options.

  • Lactaid milk comes from cows that are never treated with artificial growth hormones.


  • Real milk, no lactose. Best for people with lactose intolerance.


  • 0g added sugars (excl. chocalate milk).


Horizon Reviews

Horizon Organic milk is a delicious source of calcium & protein that kids love. Delicious, organic dairy from thier farmer partners. Horizon Organic has been pioneering organic since we started in 1991, and their practices go above and beyond USDA organic standards.

  • USDA organic standards protect cows’ time outside. Organic cows graze in the fresh air on wide open organic pastures 120 days or more each year. When weather doesn’t allow them to be outside, they eat organically approved feeds, including grain, and forage. 

  • Nature knows best! Organic cows cannot be treated with growth hormones.

  • Antibiotics are off-limits from birth for organic cows. Organic dairy farming believes that fresh air, sunshine, an organic diet, and holistic care are best to keep cows in tip-top health. That said, organic rules require that a sick cow or calf receive the care they need. If an animal becomes ill, natural and alternative methods are often used for treatment. If organic-approved treatments aren’t successful, farmers can use antibiotics or prescribed synthetic medicine to help the animal return to good health. Milk from cows treated with antibiotics cannot be used for any organic product.

  • Everything Horizon Organic cows eat must be non-GMO and organic, grown without the use of toxic persistent pesticides, herbicides, or synthetic fertilizers. This includes pasture grasses, as well as crops and feed.

  • Under organic rules, prohibited pesticides, herbicides, or synthetic fertilizers aren’t allowed on farms to protect the quality of the soil, water, and air.

image.png

Source:horizon.com

Pros & Cons

Pros Cons
  • Organic

  • Pasture-raised

  • No added hormones

  • No antibiotics

  • All-organic, non-GMO diet

  • No prohibited pesticides on the farm

  • B Corporation Certified

  • Lower in protein content.

Organic Valley Reviews

Organic Valley gives you fresh food you can trust. They let their animals grow naturally and produce milk and eggs on their own schedules. They’re never treated with synthetic hormones that could end up in your family’s food. Organic farming practices encourage regenerative agriculture techniques and diverse ecosystems, with each part nurturing the whole. These allow them to keep toxic chemicals off their farms and out of their animals' feed.

In addtion, Organic Valley farmers instead use natural holistic measures to treat animals in organic production. However, if an animal is ever sick, their farmers administer medications and the animal is permanently removed from the herd. Organic Valley offers: 

  • Milk;

  • Butter; 

  • Cheese; 

  • Cream; 

  • Eggs; 

  • Meat.

1695265685397525.png

Source:organicvalley.coop

Pros & Cons

ProsCons
  • No hormones

  • No antibiotics

  • Non GMO 

  • USDA Organic 

  • Grass-Fed

  • 0g added sugars (excl. chocalate milk)

  • The protein content of some milks are just 5g.

Where to Buy Milks?

You can buy Fairlife, Lactaid, Horizon, and Organic Valley milk on these website: 

Buy Fairlife on nearby stores.

Buy Lactaid on nearby stores.

Buy Horizon on nearby stores.

Saving Tip: If you like online shopping, don't forget to sign up at Extrabux!(What is Extrabux) , then you can enjoy up to 30+% cashback on your purchase from Extrabux! Sign-Up Bonus: Free to join it & get $20 welcome bonusStudent Benefits:As long as you are a student at school, you can get a free whole year long VIP Card worth $199.

Extrabux.com cooperates with many merchants, such as: BJ's Wholesale Club (up to 16% cashback), Walmart (Up to 4% cashback), iHerb.com (Up to 5% cashback), Sephora(4% -5% cash back), Moosejaw (5% -6% cash back), LOOKFANTASTIC (Up to 10% cash back), Giorgio Armani Beauty(10-12% cashback) )Sam's Club (Up to 15% cashback)Norton(Up to 20% cashback), Microsoft (Up to 7% cash back) and so on. You can save on buying daily necessities, fashion, beauty, electronic products, broadband installation, mobile communication, air tickets, hotels and other aspects of life! 

Fairlife vs. Lactaid vs. Horizon vs. Organic Valley

Which Milk Brand is the Best? Read on to find out.

1. Types of Milk

Fairlife offers 7 milks for you.

1. Ultra-Filtered Milk (4)
  • Fairlife 2% Ultra-Filtered Milk

  • Fairlife Whole Ultra-Filtered Milk

  • Fairlife Chocolate 2% Ultra-Filtered Milk

  • Fairlife Fat-Free Ultra-Filtered Milk

2. Ultra-Filtered Milk 14oz (3)
  • Fairlife Chocolate 2% Ultra-Filtered Milk 14oz

  • Fairlife 2% Ultra-Filtered Milk 14oz

  • Fairlife Strawberry 2% Ultra-Filtered Milk 14oz

Lactaid offers 11 milks for you. Among them, only Chocolate Milk contains lactose.

1. LACTAID Milk (4)
  • Lactose-Free Whole Milk

  • Reduced Fat 2% Lactose-Free Milk

  • Fat-Free Lactose-Free Milk

  • Lowfat 1% Lactose Free Milk

2. LACTAID Protein Milk (2)
  • Whole Milk

  • 2% Reduced Fat High Protein Milk

3. LACTAID Calcium-Enriched Milk (2)
  • Calcium-Enriched Fat Free

  • Calcium-Enriched Reduced Fat 2%

4. LACTAID Shelf-Stable Milk (2)
  • Whole Milk

  • Shelf-Stable 2% Milk

5. LACTAID Chocolate Milk (1)

Horizon offers 25 organic milks for you.

1. Organic Milk (8)
  • Whole; Reduced Fat; Lowfat; Fat-Free; 2% Chocolate; Lowfat Chocolate; Lowfat Vanilla; Lowfat Strawberry.

2. DHA Omega-3 Milk (4)
  • Whole; Reduced Fat; Lowfat Chocolate; Lowfat Vanilla.

3. Growing Years (2)
  • Whole; Reduced Fat.

4. Lactose-Free Milk (2)
  • Whole; Reduced Fat.

5. Grassfed Milk (2)
  • Whole; Reduced Fat.

6. On-the-Go (7)
  • Whole; Lowfat Chocolate with DHA Omega-3; Lowfat Vanilla with DHA Omega-3; Lowfat Chocolate; Lowfat Vanilla;  Lowfat; Lowfat Strawberry. 

Organic Valley offers 10 organic milks for you.

  • Whole Milk

  • Reduced Fat 2% Milk

  • Lowfat 1% Milk

  • Fat Free Skim Milk

  • Whole Grassmilk

  • Lactose-Free Whole Milk

  • Lowfat 1% Chocolate Milk

  • Single-Serve Chocolate Lowfat 1% Milk

  • Eggnog

  • Lowfat 1% Buttermilk

Each brand has its own type of milk that basically meets everyone's needs. People who want to lose weight can choose fat-reduced milk and fat-free milk. People who are lactose intolerant can choose lactose-free milk.

But worth noting: Horizon offers the most types of milk. Special types including: DHA Omega-3 Milk, On-the-Go, Grassfed Milk, as well as Growing Years Milk.

2. Ingredients & Nutritional Facts

Since each brand offers many products, here is a comparison of the whole milk of each brand.

Fairlife Whole Milk

Ingredients: 

  • Ultra-Filtered Milk, Lactase Enzyme, Vitamin A Palmitate, Vitamin D3.

Nutritional Facts:

image.png

Lactaid Whole Milk

Ingredients: 

  • Milk, Lactase enzyme, Vitamin D3.

Nutritional Facts:

image.png

Horizon Organic Whole Milk

Ingredients: 

  • Grade A Organic Milk, Vitamin D3.

Nutritional Facts:

image.pngimage.png

Organic Valley Whole Milk

Ingredients: 

  • Organic Grade A Milk, Vitamin D3.

Nutritional Facts:

image.png

Obviously, organic milk brands are not as good as Fairlife and Lactaid when it comes to nutrition. Organic milk brands (Horizon and Organic Valley) are missing some nutrients, such as vitamin A.

3. Price

Since each brand offers many products, here is a comparison of the whole milk of each brand.

Fairlife Whole Milk: 52 fl oz for $4.38 @walmart.com

Lactaid Whole Milk: 64 fl oz for $4.86 @walmart.com

Horizon Organic Whole Milk: 64 fl oz for $4.88 @walmart.com

Organic Valley Whole Milk: 64 fl oz for $5.22 @walmart.com

In terms of price, the Lactaid brand is the winner. If you can drink it all, it is recommended that you buy the 1 gallon size, which is cheaper per oz.

Verdict: Which Milk Brand is the Best?

These four milk brands have their own features, as detailed below:

  • Fairlife fresh milk tastes better. That's a fact. It's the reason why they take great care of their milk and quick-chilI it down to 37°, keeping it cool all the way to your local store. That's why their milk always tastes so fresh. And They flow their milk through special soft filters to concentrate the protein and calcium and filter out most of the sugar.

  • Lactaid focuses on lactose-free milks. Among the 11 milks, only chocolate milk contains lactose.

  • Horizon and Organic Valley are organic milk brands. The Horizon brand offers a much wider variety of milk than the Organic Valley brand.

All four brands offer high-quality milk. Which one is best depends on what you need. If you want to buy organic milk, you can choose Horizon and Organic Valley. If you don't mind whether the milk is organic, then it is recommended that you choose high-protein, high-calcium milk, such as Fairlife or Lactaid. All four brands offer lactose-free milk, and people with lactose intolerance can choose lactose-free milk. People who are trying to lose weight can choose fat-free milk and 2% or 1% fat-reduced milk. Chocolate or strawberry milks have a high sugar content and is not suitable for those who want to lose weight! 

Read More:

Fairlife Nutrition Plan vs. Core Power vs. Elite: Differences and Reviews 2024

8 Best Alternatives to Fairlife Protein Shakes in 2024

Horizon Organic Growing Years vs. Regular vs. DHA vs. Lcatose-Free Milk: Differences and Reviews 2024

7 Best Gift Card Exchange Sites - Buy, Sell and Trade Discount Gift Card Safely and Instanly!

Top 7 Best Websites to Buy Games for Cheap (Earn up to 6% cashback)

Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides vs. Whey Protein vs. Youtheory Collagen vs. Orgain: Which is the Best?

Ka'Chava vs. Orgain vs. Shakeology vs. Garden of Life Protein Powder: Which is Best for You?

Vital Proteins vs. Orgain vs. SkinnyFit vs. Live Conscious: Who Wins the Collagen Peptides Showdown?

Orgain vs. Garden of Life vs. Vega vs. Optimum Nutrition: Which Makes the Best Protein Powder Brand?

Vital Proteins vs. Ancient Nutrition vs. NeoCell vs. Bulletproof: Which Makes the NO.1 Collagen Brand?

3
2023-09-20 02:094360