Lotus Biscoff vs.Trader Joe's Speculoos vs. Nutella vs. Jif Peanut Butter: Which Cookie Butter is Best?

What are the most popular cookie spreads?

Some of the most popular cookie butter brands are as follows:

• Trader Joe's Speculoos Cookie Butter 

• Lotus Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter

• Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa

• Jif Creamy Peanut Butter

Do you know what the differences are between these popular spreads? My team of 10 and I tasted different brands of spreads from both domestic and international sources, and I also combined reviews from 4 different tasters to ensure you get a more complete and informed understanding.

A quick look at the differences between 4 well-known spread brands

Now, let's find out which one is the best.

	Trader Joe's Speculoos Cookie Butter	Lotus Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter	Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa	Jif Creamy Peanut Butter
	($6.91 FROM Walmart - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)	($5.47 FROM Walmart - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)	($4.47 FROM Walmart - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)	($3.28 FROM Walmart - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)
Taste:	Has warm, spiced speculoos flavor, with cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, buttery and caramel notes, cozy for mornings.	European classic, less spiced, pure cookie taste, well-balanced sweetness, elegant.	Iconic hazelnut-chocolate blend, roasted hazelnut, harmonious sweet-bitter balance.	Strong, pure roasted peanut flavor, slightly salty, great for sweet or savory.
Texture:	Velvety, spreads smoothly, right thickness for spreading and dipping.	Silky, spreads easily, adheres well, has a luxurious creaminess.	Balances thickness and spreadability, creamy, mousse-like.	Standard smooth and creamy peanut butter, normal oil separation, spreads without clumping.

Editor's review: Lotus Biscoff vs.Trader Joe's Speculoos vs. Nutella vs. Jif: Which one is best?

My number one choice is Lotus Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter!

($5.47 FROM Walmart - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

❤️ I've tried my fair share of spreads, from the classic peanut butters to the trendy cookie butters and decadent chocolate hazelnut blends. But if I had to pick a favorite, it would hands-down be Lotus Biscoff.

Let's start with my first encounter. I was on a long-haul flight, feeling a bit peckish and bored. The flight attendant came around with a little packet of Lotus Biscoff cookies, and one bite was all it took. That rich, caramelized, and ever-so-slightly spiced flavor was like a warm hug for my taste buds. I knew I had to get my hands on more of that goodness, and that's when I discovered the Lotus Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter.

When I finally got a jar of the creamy version, it was pure bliss. The texture is just out of this world. It spreads like silk on any surface, whether it's a toasted English muffin or a humble piece of wheat bread. There's no tugging, no clumping - just a smooth, even layer of that iconic Biscoff flavor. I love having it in the morning with a cup of strong coffee. The sweetness of the cookie butter pairs so well with the bitterness of the coffee, kickstarting my day on a high note.

And then there's the Lotus Biscoff Crunchy Cookie Butter. Oh my! This one takes the experience to a whole new level. The little bits of cookie in it add the most satisfying crunch. I remember making a batch of Biscoff crunch bars for a potluck. I simply melted some chocolate, mixed in the crunchy cookie butter, and let it set. They were the first thing to disappear from the dessert table! It's not just great for baking; it's also my go-to for a quick snack when I'm craving something sweet and substantial.

And let's not forget how elegant it looks and feels. The packaging is simple yet refined, and it's a spread that I'm not ashamed to have sitting out on my countertop.

On top of all that, as someone who has friends with various dietary restrictions, I appreciate that it's vegan-friendly and nut-free. It means that more people can enjoy it without any worries, and that just adds to its appeal in my book. 

Money Saving Tips First:

In fact, you can save up to 100% on online shopping at home and abroad! 

Such a high amount of cash back comes from Extrabux (What is Extrabux?), it also offers coupon codes and recent promotions, and brings together 10,000+ sites (US, China, UK, Japan, Australia , Germany, France, Italy, etc.).

Just sign up for an Extrabux account and earn exciting cash back every time you place an order via the relevant link. Sign-Up Bonus: Join for FREE & Earn $20 Welcome Bonus today! Then earn $5 Friend Referral Bonus!

Whether you are buying cheap domestic products, international luxury goods, or buying mobile phones, computers, refrigerators, washing machines, clothes, shoes, bags, mother and baby products, snacks, drinks, or booking air tickets, hotels, car rentals, or registering services and memberships , you can save money on all related purchases - save $1,000 a year!

MORE FROM

Top 10 Strongest Mints in the World 2025

Love the taste of mint? Here are some...

46455

Details

Real reviews and comparisons of the best spreads

#1. Taste: 

►    Trader Joe's Speculoos Cookie Butter: 

Opening a jar of this stuff is like unwrapping a warm, spiced holiday present. The moment it hits your taste buds, you're greeted with a medley of cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger. It has that distinct speculoos cookie flavor, which is both buttery and slightly caramelized. The spices add a depth that's cozy and comforting, making it perfect for those gray mornings when you need a little pick-me-up. 

►    Lotus Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter: 

This European classic brings a refined simplicity to the table. Its flavor is centered around the iconic Biscoff cookie, with a rich, toasted caramel note and just a hint of cinnamon. It's less overtly spiced than Trader Joe's version but offers a more pure, cookie-focused taste. The sweetness is well-balanced, never veering into cloying territory, and it has a certain elegance that keeps you coming back for more.

►    Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa: 

Nutella needs no introduction. The moment the hazelnut and cocoa blend touches your tongue, it's a match made in heaven. The hazelnuts are roasted to perfection, imparting a nutty, earthy flavor that pairs seamlessly with the rich, chocolatey goodness. It's sweet, but the bitterness of the cocoa cuts through, creating a harmonious balance that has made it a global phenomenon.

►    Jif Creamy Peanut Butter: 

Jif is the quintessential peanut butter experience. The peanuts are roasted just right, releasing a deep, nutty flavor that's both bold and familiar. There's no frills here, just pure, unadulterated peanut goodness. It has a slightly salty undertone that enhances the overall taste, making it ideal for both sweet and savory applications.

#2. Texture: 

►    Trader Joe's Speculoos Cookie Butter: 

This cookie butter has a velvety texture that spreads like a dream. Whether you're using a butter knife or a spoon, it glides across your bread or cracker, leaving a smooth, even layer. It's not too thick, so it won't tear your toast, but it also has enough body to hold its shape when you're dipping.

►    Lotus Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter: 

Similar to Trader Joe's, Lotus Biscoff is incredibly smooth. It has a consistency that's almost like silk, making it effortless to smear on any surface. It adheres well, so you don't end up with a messy, drippy situation, and it has a slight creaminess that adds to its luxurious feel.

►    Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa: 

Nutella strikes the perfect balance between thickness and spreadability. It's thick enough to stay put on a piece of bread but softens quickly upon contact, allowing you to spread it evenly. The texture is creamy and almost mousse-like in some ways, which makes it a pleasure to eat, whether you're spreading it or scooping it up with a pretzel.

►    Jif Creamy Peanut Butter: 

Jif's texture is the standard-bearer for peanut butter. It's smooth and creamy, with just the right amount of oil separation (which is normal and easily stirrable). It spreads across bread without any clumping or sticking, giving you a consistent layer of peanutty goodness.

#3. Versatility: 

►    Trader Joe's Speculoos Cookie Butter: 

It can be used in a variety of ways, such as spreading on toast, bagels, pancakes, or waffles. It can also be used as a dip for fruits, pretzels, or chocolate. Additionally, it can be used in baking to add a unique spiced flavor to cookies, cakes, or pies. And of course, it makes a mean addition to your morning oatmeal.

►    Lotus Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter: 

It is very versatile and can be used in many of the same ways as Trader Joe's Speculoos Cookie Butter. It is great for spreading on bread, making sandwiches, or using as a dip. It can also be used in baking to create delicious treats like Biscoff cookie butter cheesecake or Biscoff cookie butter cookies. It also pairs beautifully with fresh fruit, and you can use it to create a gourmet PB&J alternative by swapping out the peanut butter. It's even been known to jazz up a simple latte when used as a flavored syrup.

►    Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa: 

It is a classic chocolate spread that is great for spreading on bread, making sandwiches, or using as a dip for fruits or pretzels. It's also a favorite for dipping strawberries, creating a quick and easy dessert. It can also be used in baking to add a rich chocolate and hazelnut flavor to cakes, cookies, or brownies. 

►    Jif Creamy Peanut Butter: 

It is a staple in many households and is used in a variety of ways. It is great for spreading on bread, making sandwiches, or using as a dip for apples or celery. It can also be used in baking to make peanut butter cookies, peanut butter cups, or peanut butter brownies. It can also be used to make savory peanut sauces for stir-fries or as a base for a protein-packed smoothie. 

#4. Price: 

►    Trader Joe's Speculoos Cookie Butter: 

If you're hunting for a budget-friendly cookie butter option, Trader Joe's has you covered. In-store, you can snag a 14.1-ounce jar for a steal at around $3.99. However, if you're more of an online shopper and don't feel like making a trip to the store, things get a bit pricier. Over at Walmart, the same-sized jar will set you back $6.91, which is quite the jump from the in-store price.

►    Lotus Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter: 

Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter comes with a bit of a heftier price tag. A 14.1-ounce jar typically ranges from $5.49 to $6.49 at your local grocer. But here's a little insider tip: if you take your shopping to the web, specifically Walmart, you can find it for $5.47. And as an added bonus, you might even score 4% cash back, making it a more attractive deal than it first appears.

►    Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa: 

Nutella, the beloved hazelnut and cocoa spread, lands right in the middle of the price spectrum. Its cost varies depending on the size of the jar, but for a common 13-ounce jar, you can expect to pay around $4.50. 

►    Jif Creamy Peanut Butter: 

When it comes to affordability, Jif Creamy Peanut Butter takes the cake. A 16-ounce jar usually rings up at around $3.30. This makes it an accessible choice for families, students, or anyone looking to enjoy the classic taste of peanut butter without emptying their wallets. 

#5. Allergen Information: 

►    Trader Joe's Speculoos Cookie Butter: 

This spread contains wheat and soy, so it's not suitable for those with gluten or soy allergies. There may also be traces of milk, egg, almond, and hazelnut, so it's important to be cautious if you have severe nut allergies.

►    Lotus Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter: 

One of the perks of Lotus Biscoff is that it's vegan-friendly and nut-free. It also contains no artificial colors or flavors, making it a great choice for those with dietary restrictions or preferences.

►    Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa: 

Nutella contains hazelnuts and soy, so it's off-limits for those with nut or soy allergies. There may also be traces of other nuts and milk, so it's essential to read the label carefully.

►    Jif Creamy Peanut Butter: 

As expected, Jif contains peanuts, so it's a no-go for those with peanut allergies. There may also be traces of other nuts and soy, so always double-check the label.

#6. Real reviews from users:

►    Trader Joe's Speculoos Cookie Butter: 

Review 1: I'm absolutely obsessed with Trader Joe's Speculoos Cookie Butter! The moment I opened the jar, the warm, cinnamon-y scent hit me, and I knew it was going to be good. The texture is so creamy, it spreads like a dream on my morning toast. It has that perfect balance of sweetness and spice, just like a freshly baked speculoos cookie. I also love using it as a dip for apple slices - it gives a fun, autumnal twist to a simple snack. It's such a great value for the price, and I always make sure to have a backup jar in my pantry.

Review 2: This cookie butter is a game-changer! I was initially skeptical because I'm not the biggest fan of overly sweet spreads, but the spices in Trader Joe's Speculoos really temper the sugar. It's got a rich, buttery undertone that pairs beautifully with a hot cup of coffee. I've even used it in some baking experiments, swirling it into brownie batter, and the result was divine. The only downside is that it can be a bit addictive - I find myself sneaking spoonfuls straight from the jar!

Review 3: Trader Joe's has done it again! The Speculoos Cookie Butter is a staple in my household now. My kids go crazy for it. It's so easy to spread on their after-school snacks, whether it's a baguette slice or a graham cracker. The packaging is also really convenient; the jar is easy to open and close, which is important when you have little hands trying to get into it. The flavor is consistent, and it always tastes fresh, no matter how long it's been in the pantry.

Review 4: I picked up this cookie butter on a whim, and I'm so glad I did. It has a unique flavor profile compared to other spreads I own. The speculoos flavor is so authentic, and it's got this lovely, soft texture that makes it a pleasure to eat. I've used it to make a speculoos and banana sandwich, and it was heavenly. It's also great for when you're entertaining; guests always comment on how delicious it is when paired with some fresh fruit.

►    Lotus Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter: 

Review 1: Lotus Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter is pure luxury in a jar. I first had it on a flight, and I knew I had to buy it immediately. The taste is so rich and smooth, with that distinct caramelized cookie flavor. It spreads evenly on any surface, whether it's a piece of toasted brioche or a simple digestive biscuit. I appreciate that it's vegan-friendly, which means more of my friends can enjoy it. It's a bit on the pricier side, but for the quality and flavor, it's worth every penny.

Review 2: I've been searching for the perfect cookie butter, and Lotus Biscoff is it. The consistency is just right - not too thick, not too thin. The flavor is so well-balanced; it's sweet but not sickly, and the hint of cinnamon gives it an extra layer of depth. I use it to make a quick and easy dessert by layering it with whipped cream and fresh berries. It's also great for those late-night cravings when you want something sweet but not too heavy.

Review 3: This Biscoff cookie butter has become my go-to spread. I love that it doesn't have any artificial colors or flavors. It has a very pure, clean taste that really showcases the cookie essence. I often take it to work and spread it on a rice cake for a mid-morning snack. It keeps me full and satisfied, and the flavor lingers in a really pleasant way. The packaging is elegant, and it looks great on my countertop, too.

Review 4: I'm a huge fan of European treats, and Lotus Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter fits the bill perfectly. It's so versatile - I've used it in cheesecake recipes, and it adds a wonderful, crunchy texture when you mix in some crushed Biscoff cookies. The creamy version on its own is a delight, though. It's like having a jar full of melted Biscoff cookies, and I can't get enough of it. Whether I'm having it with tea or as part of a more elaborate dessert, it never disappoints.

►    Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa: 

Review 1: Nutella is a household name for a reason! The Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa is an absolute classic. The hazelnut flavor is so intense and nutty, and it pairs perfectly with the rich chocolate. It's the ultimate spread for my kids' sandwiches - they prefer it over peanut butter any day. The texture is smooth and creamy, and it spreads effortlessly on bread, even when it's straight out of the fridge. It's also great for dipping pretzels or strawberries; it just makes everything taste better.

Review 2: I grew up with Nutella, and it still holds a special place in my heart (and my pantry). The combination of hazelnuts and cocoa is a match made in heaven. It has a slightly thicker texture near the edges of the jar, which I actually love because it gives a bit more substance when you're spreading it. I use it to make Nutella crepes on lazy Sundays, and it's the easiest, most delicious breakfast. The price is fair considering the quality of the ingredients, and it's always in stock at my local grocery store.

Review 3: Nutella is my go-to when I'm craving something sweet and indulgent. The balance between the sweetness of the chocolate and the earthy hazelnuts is spot-on. I've experimented with using it in baking, like making Nutella brownies, and the result is always a rich, decadent treat. It's also really convenient; the jar is easy to handle, and the label clearly shows all the nutritional information. I just wish they made an even larger size for my big family!

Review 4: I'm a chocoholic, and Nutella is my weakness. The Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa has a luxurious feel to it. It's not just a spread; it's a flavor enhancer. I've added it to my coffee for a DIY hazelnut mocha, and it worked like a charm. The spreadability is excellent, and it doesn't leave any clumps on my toast. Whether it's for an afternoon snack or a late-night dessert, Nutella is always there to satisfy my cravings.

►    Jif Creamy Peanut Butter: 

Review 1: Jif Creamy Peanut Butter is the real deal. I've been buying it for years, and it never disappoints. The peanut flavor is so strong and pure, and it has that perfect roasted taste. It's incredibly versatile - I use it to make classic peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, of course, but also to make peanut sauce for my stir-fries. The texture is smooth and creamy, and it mixes well with other ingredients. It's also very affordable, which is a huge plus for my family on a budget.

Review 2: I'm a peanut butter purist, and Jif is my top pick. It spreads easily on bread, and it has a nice, thick consistency that doesn't drip all over the place. I love the slightly salty undertone; it adds a bit of contrast to the natural sweetness of the peanuts. I often have it with celery sticks as a healthy snack. It's got a great shelf life, too, so I can stock up without worrying about it going bad quickly. It's just a reliable, delicious peanut butter.

Review 3: Jif has been a staple in my kitchen since I was a kid. The creamy version is so easy to work with, whether I'm baking peanut butter cookies or just having a quick snack. It's got a great balance of oil and peanut solids, so it's never too greasy or too dry. I also appreciate that it comes in different sizes, so I can choose the one that best fits my needs. It's a classic for a reason, and I don't see myself switching to any other brand anytime soon.

Review 4: This peanut butter is amazing! The flavor of Jif Creamy Peanut Butter is so full-bodied. I've used it to make a peanut butter smoothie, and it added a great deal of creaminess and protein. It's so simple yet so good. The packaging is user-friendly, and the lid seals tightly, keeping the peanut butter fresh. It's the kind of product that I can always count on to satisfy my peanut butter cravings, no matter what time of day.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the "best" spread depends entirely on your personal preferences. If you're a fan of warm, spiced flavors and want an affordable option for baking, Trader Joe's Speculoos Cookie Butter is a winner. For those seeking a more refined, nut-free cookie butter with a European flair, Lotus Biscoff takes the cake. Chocolate and hazelnut addicts will always reach for Nutella, while peanut butter purists can't go wrong with Jif. So, the next time you're standing in the grocery aisle, armed with this knowledge, you can make the spread choice that will satisfy your taste buds and fit your lifestyle.

My number one choice is Lotus Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter!

($5.47 FROM Walmart - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

Between the unbeatable taste, the luxurious textures, and its all-around user-friendly nature, Lotus Biscoff has truly stolen my heart - and my taste buds!

More：

Extrabux is an international cashback shopping site, offering up to 30% cashback from 10,000+ Stores!

Squarespace, SkinStore, MATCHESFASHION, The Wall Street Journal, NordVPN, Visible, Armani Exchange, Sam's Club, PUMA, AliExpress, Card Cash, NET-A-PORTER, Udacity, Udemy, Selfridges, LOOKFANTASTIC, Vimeo, Coach Outlet, lululemon, PrettyLittleThing, Booking.com, Ripley's Aquarium, iHerb, Groupon, etc.

Join to get $20 welcome bonus now! (How does Welcome Bonus work?)