12 Best Extra Virgin Olive Oil Brands from Italy, Spain, Greece, and the U.S.

Are you tired of standing in the grocery aisle, bewildered by the countless bottles of extra virgin olive oil, each claiming to be the best? But how do you cut through the marketing hype and find the true gems? That's precisely what we're here to do. We're pulling back the veil on the 12 best extra virgin olive oil brands from these four remarkable regions:

#1. California Olive Ranch: 

($16.99, was $21.99 FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($17.34 FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

►    Brand Introduction: 

Hailing from the sunny groves of California, this brand has made a name for itself with its commitment to quality. Their olives are grown under optimal conditions, and the oils are certified extra virgin by third - party labs.

►    Product Recommendation: 

If you're on the hunt for an olive oil that strikes the perfect balance between quality, flavor, and versatility, then the California Olive Ranch Global Blend Extra Virgin Olive Oil deserves a prime spot in your pantry.

This Global Blend is a symphony of tastes. It marries the bright, grassy notes that are characteristic of Californian olives with the rich, earthy undertones from olives sourced across the globe. 

The result? A well-rounded flavor that's neither too overpowering nor too mild. Whether you're drizzling it over a simple garden salad, where it'll add a fresh zing, or using it to sauté a medley of vegetables, the flavor will gently infuse your ingredients without stealing the show.

When it comes to price, this olive oil offers remarkable value. It typically falls within a mid-range price bracket, making it accessible for regular home cooks who don't want to break the bank but still demand quality. 

►    User Reviews: 

"I've been using California Olive Ranch for years. It's always consistent, and I love that it's so affordable. I use it for everything from frying eggs to making my mom's famous olive oil cake," says one long - time user. Another adds, "It comes in dark green glass bottles, is easy to pour, and has a light, slightly grassy neutral flavor with a bit of throat bitterness. The flavor is just right - not too strong, so it pairs well with all my favorite recipes."

#2. Graza: 

($14.99 FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($16.99 FROM Target)

►    Brand Introduction: 

Graza burst onto the scene in 2022, revolutionizing olive oil packaging with its squeezable bottles. Sourced from the olive - rich regions of Spain, specifically using Picual olives.

They source their olives from the renowned Picual olive groves in Spain, focusing on single-origin oils for a distinct flavor profile.

►    Product Recommendation: 

The "Sizzle" oil is perfect for cooking. It has a mild, fruity flavor that can handle high heat without breaking down. For a more intense, finishing touch, the "Drizzle" oil, made from younger olives, is ideal.

Graza® Sizzle is a mild-mannered superstar. It has a flavor that's both fruity and approachable, making it an ideal companion for all kinds of cooking. Whether you're whipping up a classic Italian pasta sauce, sautéing a pan of garlicky shrimp, or even just frying an egg for breakfast, the Sizzle oil imparts a gentle, olivey essence without overwhelming your dish. 

The name "Sizzle" isn't just for show. This oil has a decent smoke point, which means it can handle the heat of your stovetop. No more worrying about your olive oil breaking down and ruining the flavor of your food during high-heat cooking. 

When it comes to price, Graza® Sizzle offers great value. The set of "Drizzle" and "Sizzle" oils is priced at around $37 on Graza. The individual bottles are also available at different price points, with the 750 mL "Sizzle" bottle costing about $16.

►    User Reviews: 

A busy mom shared, "I used to be intimidated by cooking with olive oil, but Graza® Sizzle changed that. The squeeze bottle is so easy to use, and the oil has a light enough flavor that my picky kids don't even notice it in their food, but I know they're getting something healthy." 

#3. Bertolli Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Rich Taste: 

($14.99, was $16.99 FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($14.97 FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

►    Brand Introduction: 

Bertolli is an Italian institution, with a heritage dating back to the 19th century. Their extra virgin olive oil is affordable and widely available, making it a staple in many kitchens.

►    Product Recommendation: 

Bertolli's Extra Virgin Olive Oil with a Rich Taste is a must-have in any kitchen. It combines the allure of Italian heritage, a bold flavor profile, and a price point that won't break the bank, making it the perfect partner for all your cooking endeavors.

Right out of the green plastic bottle, you notice its heftier, more viscous consistency compared to run-of-the-mill olive oils. It pours slowly, hinting at the richness to come. 

Its bold, fruity flavor can transform a simple pasta sauce from bland to bold. The thicker texture holds up well during cooking, whether you're sautéing onions or searing meats. And for those who love a bit of zing in their salads, a drizzle of this oil adds a peppery, olivey depth that pairs beautifully with greens and tomatoes.

The price is a definite plus - at just $9.47 for 500 mL at Walmart, it's wallet-friendly, making it accessible for everyday cooks looking to add a touch of quality to their meals.

►    User Reviews: 

"I grew up using Bertolli, and it's still my go-to. The flavor is so robust, and it really makes my Italian dishes taste like they came from a trattoria," says one user. Another adds, "I use the Light Olive Oil for frying, and it never leaves a greasy residue. It's great quality for the price."

#4. García de la Cruz Mild & Smooth Everyday Use Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil: 

($17.99 FROM Amazon  - Save 10%)

($47.84, Pack of 4 FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

►    Brand Introduction: 

This family-owned business has been operating since 1872, making it a well-established and respected name in the olive oil industry. García de la Cruz is particularly known for its commitment to quality and authenticity, working to bring the finest Spanish olive oils to consumers around the world.

►    Product Recommendation: 

Today I want to introduce you to García de la Cruz Everyday Use Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil. This olive oil is characterized by its mild and smooth flavor profile. It has a delicate, fruity aroma that is not overpowering, making it a versatile choice for various dishes. 

Users have been highly praising this olive oil for its consistent quality and pleasant taste. Many appreciate its mildness, which allows the natural flavors of the food to shine through. It has been described as a "go-to" oil for those who prefer a more subtle olive oil flavor in their cooking. Some users also like that it is organic and comes with various certifications, giving them peace of mind about the product's origin and production methods.

►    User Reviews: 

"As someone who pays attention to healthy eating, I am extremely satisfied with this olive oil. Its taste is mild and delicate, without any bitter or pungent flavor, allowing me to enjoy delicious food while taking in healthy fats. I also like to use it for marinating meat and vegetables as it can greatly enhance the flavor of the ingredients. In addition, its packaging is also very beautiful, adding a touch of class to my kitchen. I highly recommend it to everyone."

#5. Gaea Fresh Extra Virgin Olive Oil: 

($24.99 FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($22.46 FROM iHerb   - Get Up To 7% Cash Back)

►    Brand Introduction: 

One of the most globally recognized Greek olive oil brands, Gaea offers a diverse range of extra virgin olive oils. The brand is committed to sustainable farming practices, ensuring both the quality of their products and the environmental impact.

►    Product Recommendation: 

Their Gaea Fresh variety is highly recommended. 

This extra virgin olive oil is made from the Chorai Tiki variety, harvested early to maintain high polyphenol levels. It has a medium intensity with an acidity level of less than 0.4%. The flavor profile is characterized by a strong fruity aroma, followed by notes of artichoke and freshly mown grass, more pungent than bitter, thanks to its rich polyphenol content.

The regular price of Gaea Fresh Extra Virgin Olive Oil is $26.95 for a 16.9 oz bottle. It can also be found on iHerb and Vitacost, with prices varying slightly depending on the retailer and any ongoing promotions.

►    User Reviews: 

Many users praise its lovely taste and color, describing it as a step above the rest. It is highly regarded for its excellent flavor, making it a great choice for salad dressings, marinating, and as a finishing oil for pasta, sauces, dips, and hummus. Some also appreciate its organic and carbon-neutral certifications, as well as its well-designed packaging and user-friendly spout. However, there were a few negative reviews, with one user receiving a bottle that was not fresh and had a short use-by date.

#6. Filippo Berio Extra Virgin Olive Oil: 

($13.99 FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($12.47 FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

►    Brand Introduction: 

Another Italian heavyweight, Filippo Berio has been producing olive oil since 1867. With a global presence, this brand is known for its consistency and affordability. 

►    Product Recommendation: 

When it comes to stocking your pantry with affordable olive oil, Filippo Berio's Extra Virgin Olive Oil often finds its way onto the shopping list. 

When you crack open a bottle of high-quality olive oil, you expect a rich, inviting aroma to fill the air. Filippo Berio falls short in this department. It's odd because, despite the lackluster scent, the taste is quite strong once it hits your tongue.

Filippo Berio Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a bit of a mixed bag. If you're on a tight budget and need a large quantity of olive oil for basic cooking, marinating, or making simple dressings, it could be a good fit. However, if you're someone who values a strong, inviting aroma and more consistent flavor over the long term, you might want to explore other options on the market.

►    User Reviews: 

"I grew up with Filippo Berio in my grandma's pantry. It's not the fanciest, but it's reliable and affordable. I still use it for big - batch cooking," a nostalgic user says.

#7. Colavita Premium Selection Extra Virgin Olive Oil: 

($21.18 FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($21.99, was $25.99 FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

►    Brand Introduction: 

A family-owned Italian brand with over 100 years of history in producing high-quality edible oils. They use special techniques to create pure, flavorful, and nutritious products.

►    Product Recommendation: 

The Premium Selection extra virgin olive oil is a flavor powerhouse. It greets you with a robust aroma that's both grassy and fruity, hinting at the fresh olives it's sourced from. On the palate, there's a beautiful balance. The initial taste is smooth, almost buttery, which quickly gives way to a lively, peppery kick at the back. This complexity makes it perfect for a wide array of dishes. Drizzle it over a simple Caprese salad, and it'll enhance the sweetness of the tomatoes and creaminess of the mozzarella, while the peppery note adds a little zing.

►    User Reviews: 

One home cook gushed, "I've been using Colavita's Premium Selection for years, and it never disappoints. It makes my homemade pizza crusts crispy on the outside and tender on the inside, and the flavor is just out of this world." Another user, more into salads, shared, "I use it to make my vinaigrettes, and it emulsifies beautifully. The flavor is so intense that I only need a little bit to transform an ordinary salad into something special."

#8. Pompeian® Robust Extra Virgin Olive Oil: 

($15.32 FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($15.99 FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

►    Brand Introduction: 

Hailing from Spain, Pompeian is highly regarded in the US for its commitment to providing fresh, natural, and top-quality olive oil products.

►    Product Recommendation: 

The Pompeian® Robust Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a classic choice. It combines a bold flavor profile, reliable quality, and wallet-friendly pricing, ensuring that it can become the go-to olive oil for elevating your culinary creations.

True to its name, this olive oil is robust! The moment you uncork the bottle, a rich, intense aroma fills the air. It has a deep, earthy base, reminiscent of sun-kissed olive groves, layered with bright, zesty notes. There's a pleasant bitterness that dances on your taste buds, quickly followed by a peppery finish that lingers, adding a bit of heat and excitement to every bite. This makes it the perfect candidate for dishes that can stand up to bold flavors, like a hearty Italian Bolognese or a grilled steak.

►    User Reviews: 

One home cook raved, "I used to use plain olive oil, but once I tried Pompeian's Robust, there was no going back. It makes my pasta sauces taste like they came from a high-end trattoria. The peppery kick is addictive!" Another user, a grill master, shared, "I brush this oil on my steaks before grilling, and it forms the most amazing crust. The flavor it imparts is out of this world, and it keeps the meat juicy."

#9. Bragg® Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil: 

($19.40 FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($20.99 FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

►    Brand Introduction: 

Operating since 1912, Bragg is known for its commitment to providing simple and healthy products. Their organic olive oil is part of their range of natural and nutritious offerings.

►    Product Recommendation: 

Bragg Organic Olive Oil is a great choice for those looking for an organic and healthy option. This organic extra virgin olive oil has a mild, yet incredibly pleasant flavor. It doesn't hit you with an overpowering punch; instead, it offers a gentle, buttery smoothness on the palate. There are delicate, fruity undertones that add a touch of freshness, making it perfect for those who prefer a subtler olive oil flavor in their dishes. Whether you're drizzling it over a bed of mixed greens for a light salad or using it to marinate delicate fish, it enhances the natural flavors without overwhelming them.

It typically retails for around $20 for a 16-ounce bottle. While it might be a bit more expensive than some mass-market olive oils, the value it offers in terms of health benefits, flavor, and versatility more than justifies the cost.

►    User Reviews: 

One health enthusiast shared, "I love Bragg's olive oil because it fits my organic lifestyle perfectly. I use it in my morning smoothie for an extra dose of healthy fats, and it doesn't change the flavor too much. It just gives it a nice, smooth texture." Another home cook commented, "I make a lot of vegan dishes, and this olive oil is my go-to. It's so versatile, and I know I'm getting a clean product that's good for me and my family."

#10. Spectrum® Organic Unrefined Extra Virgin Olive Oil : 

($25.67 FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($21.99 FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

►    Brand Introduction: 

Spectrum is dedicated to providing natural and organic food products, including a range of high-quality olive oils. They source their olives carefully and use gentle extraction methods to preserve the oil's nutrients and flavor.

►    Product Recommendation: 

Spectrum® Organic Unrefined Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a must-have for those who value flavor, quality, and health in their cooking. 

When you first open the bottle, a rich, intense aroma hits you – it's like taking a stroll through a sun-drenched olive grove. The flavor on the palate is bold, with deep, fruity notes that are both sweet and tart, reminiscent of ripe olives just plucked from the tree. There's also a pleasant, peppery kick at the end that lingers, adding an exciting dimension to any dish. It's the kind of oil that can transform a simple salad into a gourmet masterpiece or breathe new life into a tired pasta sauce.

When it comes to price, Spectrum® Organic Unrefined Extra Virgin Olive Oil sits in the mid - to upper - mid range. While it might seem a bit pricier upfront, it's important to consider the value it brings. 

►    User Reviews: 

One home cook raved, "I used to buy generic olive oils, but once I tried Spectrum's unrefined version, I was hooked. It makes my roasted chicken taste like it came from a fancy bistro. The flavor is so intense and pure!" Another user, a salad enthusiast, shared, "I make the most incredible salad dressings with this oil. It gives my greens a zesty, fresh kick that I just can't get with other oils."

#11. La Tourangelle Organic Bright & Peppery Extra Virgin Olive Oil: 

($19.98 FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

►    Brand Introduction: 

Based in France, La Tourangelle is a family-owned business that has been producing high-quality oils since 1981. Their olive oil is sourced from Spain, and they use a slow, cold-pressing process to extract the oil, resulting in a bright, peppery flavor.

►    Product Recommendation: 

This organic extra virgin olive oil is cold-pressed from Spanish Picual olives harvested early in Andalucía, Spain. The quick processing after harvest preserves the olives' high antioxidant levels, resulting in a well-balanced, extra fresh oil. 

The flavor of this olive oil is bold and intense, with hints of freshly cut grass, almond, and fresh olive leaves, followed by a peppery finish. It is a well-balanced sage green oil that is both fruity and aromatic. The high-quality production process and organic sourcing ensure that you are getting a pure and healthy product, rich in polyphenols, vitamin E, K, and beneficial fatty acids.

It is suitable for medium-high heat cooking, making it perfect for sautéing, baking, marinating, and more. You can also use it to make delicious salad dressings or simply drizzle it over your favorite dishes for an extra burst of flavor.

►    User Reviews: 

"I love the La Tourangelle. It's easy to pour, and the flavor is so clean. It's my go-to for simple salads," says one user. Another adds, "The Roasted Garlic Infused Olive Oil is amazing. It adds a delicious garlic flavor to my pasta and roasted vegetables."

#12. De Cecco Classic Extra Virgin Olive Oil: 

($17.80 FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

►    Brand Introduction: 

Mainly known for its pasta, De Cecco also produces excellent extra virgin olive oil. The brand is committed to using high-quality ingredients and traditional production techniques to ensure the authenticity and superior taste of its olive oil.

►    Product Recommendation: 

De Cecco's Classic Extra Virgin Olive Oil has a mild yet utterly charming flavor. When you uncork the bottle, a delicate, fruity aroma wafts out, hinting at the fresh olives that have been carefully pressed. On the palate, it's smooth as silk, with a gentle nuttiness that pairs beautifully with a wide array of ingredients. It doesn't overwhelm your taste buds but rather adds a refined, understated note to dishes. Whether you're dressing a simple salad of mixed greens or sautéing some garlic and onions for a pasta sauce, this oil imparts a clean, fresh flavor.

Generally in the mid-range, offering good value for money considering the brand's reputation and the quality of the product.

►    User Reviews: 

One home cook shared, "I've always trusted De Cecco for pasta, so I decided to try their olive oil. I'm so glad I did! It's become my go-to for making quick weeknight salads. The flavor is just right, and it makes the greens taste so fresh." Another user, more into baking, said, "I use it in my olive oil cakes, and it gives them a moist, tender crumb. The flavor is so subtle that it doesn't compete with the other ingredients, but you can still tell it's there."

In conclusion, these 12 extra virgin olive oil brands offer a diverse range of flavors and qualities to suit every palate and cooking need. Whether you're looking for a bold and robust oil for drizzling or a milder option for cooking, you're sure to find the perfect one among these top picks.

More：

Extrabux is an international cashback shopping site, offering up to 30% cashback from 10,000+ Stores!

Squarespace, SkinStore, MATCHESFASHION, The Wall Street Journal, NordVPN, Visible, Armani Exchange, Sam's Club, PUMA, AliExpress, Card Cash, NET-A-PORTER, Udacity, Udemy, Selfridges, LOOKFANTASTIC, Vimeo, Coach Outlet, lululemon, PrettyLittleThing, Booking.com, Ripley's Aquarium, iHerb, Groupon, etc.

Join to get $20 welcome bonus now! (How does Welcome Bonus work?)