Tecovas vs. Ariat vs. Justin Boots vs. Cody James: Who Wins the Cowboy Boots Brand Showdown?

• Tecovas

Tecovas History and Origin

Founded by Paul Hedrick in 2015,Tecovas is a young brand.The story goes that Paul, a Texas native, was living in Connecticut and was having a hard time finding a good pair of cowboy boots in the city. Eventually, the nostalgia was too strong, and he was itching to start his own company and leave the corporate lifestyle and big city behind. So he returned to his roots in Austin and started Tecovas. 

Though the brand is relatively new, its mission is to provide timeless cowboy boots handcrafted from materials that are meant to last decades—and remain stylish for just as long. Favoring more understated designs with longevity in mind, Tecovas boots are meticulously made by hand in Léon, Mexico in a process that requires over 200 steps. Every boot is crafted with top-quality materials under the expert eyes and hands of Tecovas’ team of artisans.

The brand offers a limited range of cowboy boots in both men's and women's sizes, but almost every style is available in a variety of colorways and materials, from bovine to suede. Tecovas also creates their boots in multiple lengths, with the shortest being an ankle-height mule and the tallest a knee-high boot. In addition to cowboy boots, Tecovas also sells apparel, bags, and accessories, though they were not included in this test.

Tecovas Boots Prices

Unlike those rarified luxury bootmakers, Tecovas offers their goods at surprisingly affordable prices since they cut out third-party retailers.What you get is a traditionally handmade cowboy boot with premium leather — including many exotics like sharkskin, stacked leather heels, and authentic lemon wood pegging. These are some of the best cowboy boots you can get, especially at this price point. 

Tecovas offer handmade western boots for men and women. For women, the price range is just north of $210 up to about $995. For men, it’s similar – although there are a few premium exotic styles that top out at $1,995.In my opinion, Tecovas is the way to go if you’re looking for a traditional cowboy boot at a reasonable price. 

Tecovas Boots Design & Style

Tecovas focuses on a more refined, classic Western aesthetic.The brand offers a few different combinations of boot designs, but in essence, it breaks down to a combination of round or square toe, and short or tall heel (a few more variations include a wedge sole, zipper shaft, and Chelsea.) From there, each style is defined by a combination of design features and a different hide. 

While Tecovas currently offers 11 cowboy boot styles for women, there are over 40 variations to choose from, thanks to the many colorways and materials available in each design. 

Tecovas Boots Quality & Material

Tecovas boots are made in Leon, Mexico, by a skilled team of craftspeople. Each boot undergoes around 200 separate stages of construction. The firm claims their quality is twice that of similarly priced brands, and compares to that of boots costing twice as much.Here are some of the materials commonly used in Tecovas boots:

• Full-grain leather: Tecovas boots are made with full-grain leather, which is the highest quality and most durable type of leather. Full-grain leather is made from the top layer of the cowhide and retains the natural grain and texture of the hide, giving the boots a rich, natural look and feel.

• Cowhide lining: The interior of Tecovas boots is lined with soft, supple cowhide leather, which provides a comfortable fit and helps the boots conform to the wearer’s feet over time.

• Leather outsole: Tecovas boots feature a leather outsole, which is durable and provides good traction. The leather outsole is also more breathable than synthetic materials, helping to keep the feet cool and dry.

• Cushioned insole: Tecovas boots come with a cushioned insole that provides additional comfort and support. The insole is designed to conform to the shape of the foot, providing a customized fit.

• Steel shank: Tecovas boots feature a steel shank in the midsole, which provides additional support and stability. The steel shank helps to distribute weight evenly across the foot, reducing foot fatigue and improving comfort.

Tecovas Boots Pros and Cons

Where to Buy Tecovas Boots?

Tecovas boots are only available for purchase online or at their retail stores.You can buy cowbot boots from their official website.

• Ariat

Ariat History and Origin

Established in 1993, two men worked for the existence of Ariat International. They are known as Beth Cross and Pam Parker.Ariat was founded as “The New Breed of Boot.” They were the first to integrate athletic footwear technology into boots for equestrian athletes. Today, their world-class product team builds innovative and award-winning performance products for all types of outdoor and work environments. In the year 2012, a renowned wealthy family called The Fishers Family, a major shareholder in other companies, bought the clothing company known as Ariat International.The Fishers Family declared their commitment to helping Ariat International with their goal at that time, which was global expansion.In order to achieve this, they turned Ariat into a lifestyle brand. 

In 2020, Ariat International was recognized as the largest equestrian apparel and footwear company, owing to its global expansion in sales in countries like the United States, Japan, Mexico, Europe, and Australia.Ariat has been around about two decades longer than Tecovas. And their range of styles is about 20 times larger.

If it's a bona fide Western boot you want, a bona fide Western is what you're going to get when the tag says Ariat. To wit: the brand is the official sponsor of Professional Bull Riders—and it doesn't get any more cowboy than that, folks. Ariat not only uses advanced technology to make their products, but they also were the first company to integrate athletic footwear properties into their boots, so in other words, all of their products are comfy as hell.There are styles for everyone, men, women and kids.

Ariat Boots Prices

Ariat boots are generally less expensive than Tecovas. Generally, Ariat boots can vary in price depending on the style and features.The brand's cowboy boots and western boots can cost from $160 to $750., with something for everyone.

Ariat Boots Desogn & Style

Ariat manufactures a variety of boots, some of which include the American flag in addition to peculiar stitching patterns that give the impression that a dinosaur tore through the front of the leather.If you prefer to have real leather that ages well rather than having a camouflage pattern or mesh vent panels on the side of the shoes, then Ariat boots may not be for you. 

Ariat Boots Quality & Material

More traditional bootmakers will keep to staid materials and techniques, but Ariat embraces modern materials that offer comfort, breathability, and longevity along with leather uppers and old-school stitching.The rigorous manufacturing process involves up to 150 separate stages, producing boots that can last for years.

Ariat riding boots are made from excellent quality full-grain leather. Full grain leathers have little imperfections which make them so perfect. The brand also uses Top Grain Leather to make its riding boots. In recent times synthetic materials are also being used to make shoes.

Ariat not only uses advanced technology to make their products, but they also were the first company to integrate athletic footwear properties into their boots, so in other words, all of their products are comfy as hell.You’ll find padded insoles, non-slip soles, breathable lining and waterproof construction. Everything, in fact, to keep you comfortable in the saddle or on the dance floor. If you choose Ariat, you’ll be in good company: their boots are worn by many professional riders.

Ariat Boots Pros and Cons

Where to Buy Ariat Boots?

Ariat official website(up to 7% super cash back)

Bootbarn.com

Amazon

Saving Tip:

If you like online shopping, don't forget to sign up at Extrabux！(What is Extrabux) , then you can enjoy up to 30+% cashback on your purchase from Extrabux! Sign-Up Bonus: Free to join it & get $20 welcome bonus! Student Benefits：As long as you are a student at school, you can get a free whole year long VIP Card worth $199.

Extrabux.com cooperates with many merchants, such as: Walmart (Up to 4% cashback), Sephora（4% -5% cash back)，Dior (Up to 6% cash back), Moosejaw (5% -6% cash back), LOOKFANTASTIC (Up to 10% cash back), Microsoft (Up to 7% cash back) and so on. You can save on buying daily necessities, fashion, beauty, electronic products, broadband installation, mobile communication, air tickets, hotels and other aspects of life!

• Justin Boots

Justin Boots History and Origin

Justin is another brand with an illustrious history. Founded in 1879 by H. J. Justin, it started life as a boot repair service in a barber shop. Justin convinced the barbershop owner (where his business was located) that he can manufacture the world’s best boots, and he was eventually given the $35 he needed to jumpstart Justin Boots. The first designs had straightforward designs that were built with lasting strength. With the entrepreneurial Justin at the helm, it quickly grew to a successful boot store.By 1908, his sons joined the business, and with the combined efforts, the company doubled its production. It is said that the patterns that many cowboy boot designers use today are all originally Justin’s designs.His sons took over the company when he passed away in 1918, and the headquarters was moved to Fort Worth. This period also saw the company start using machine technology to produce high-quality boots in its factories.

A century later, Justin boots are still the standard of the West and are also described as the “Best Looking, and Best Made Boots in America.”Today, the brand offers a broader selection of leathers and styles. They also make cowboy boots for every need: rugged work boots, Wellingtons, Ropers, Ranch Ropers, and even the beloved safety steel toe work boot. If you want to complete the look, Justin also makes a range of apparel, with everything from socks to hoodies available.

Justin Boots Prices

Justin Boots, the iconic Texas footwear brand, has more than a 140-year history, and a continued stellar reputation for producing some of the best cowboy boots around. Amazingly, the brand still makes its boots in El Paso (they source the leather and other materials worldwide) and offer them at a fair price. The boots range from around $100 for a basic roper — a style with a lower shaft and square heel — to $660 for more exotic selections. 

Justin Boots Design & Style

Justin Boots has a vast selection of styles, from classic cowboy boots to work boots and more contemporary designs, while Cody James often focuses on unique, detailed designs with intricate stitching and embellishments.

Justin Boots’ range of cowboy boots and western-inspired work boots are yet another excellent entrypoint for the budget-minded. Whether you're into the more audacious designs or prefer a modest western boot, the brand's got a pair worth considering.

Justin Boots Quality & Material

Justin is a name synonymous with good cowboy boots. They say that it takes about six weeks to make a pair of Justin cowboy boots. Each pair is still hand-lasted and requires about 200 steps to make each Justin cowboy boot.

Justin uses only the finest quality leather and other components to create tough yet comfortable to use Western boots. The company has expert boot makers who work on handcrafting the different boot styles, although some are now being built using machine technology. 

Justin also uses patented technology to boost the function and comfort of its Western boots. The signature J-Bar technology features leather strongly resistant to barnyard acids, ensuring that the boots won’t deteriorate when exposed to harsh chemicals often encountered in outdoor work environments.Justin’s Grip on Demand technology uses special design enhancements to boost the outsoles’ grip. Outsoles are built with grooves for a stronger hold on the stirrup when the boot flexes, while easily letting go of its grip once the sole is flattened. This design also strengthens the outsoles’ grip on slick surfaces.Justin’s partnership with Vibram created outsoles that specifically cater to outdoor leisure and work activities.

Justin Boots Pros and Cons

Where to Buy Justin Boots?

Justin Boots official website

Amazon

Bootbarn.com

• Cody James

Cody James History and Origin

Cody James has been handcrafting quality western wear since 1879. Their founder James Cody opened his first boot shop in Texas and soon gained a reputation for making some of the finest, most comfortable boots around. It was founded in Arkansas. But now this brand has merged with BOOT barn and sold under their brand name. It is situated in California, USA. 

Over the decades the brand has  expanded the collection to offer all the essentials for classic American cowboy style. They now carry boots, hats, jeans, shirts, belts, wallets and more. Cody James embodies the true American cowboy, who lives and breathes the country western lifestyle.

The reviews about Cody James cowboy boots are promising – they use good leather, and the range of styles and colors offered are excellent. However, it is evident that they manufacture these boots using machines in facilities in Asian countries. If you do not mind that they are foreign-made, this is an affordable brand of cowboy boots to try.

Cody James Boots Prices

The price of Cody James boots ranges between $100 – $900 depending on materials and construction. Leather boots represent the best value.

Cody James Boots Design & Style

Cody James often focuses on unique, detailed designs with intricate stitching and embellishments.It is a more affordable option with a classic Western look.The brand offers several collections including vintage-inspired Heritage boots, rugged Work/Western boots, slip-on Chelsea boots, and motorcycle-styled Engineer boots. No matter your personal style or intended use, Cody James has a versatile pair of boots for you. 

Cody James Quality & Material

Every Cody James product is meticulously made using techniques passed down through generations. Their leather boots feature full-grain uppers, leather linings, and hand-stitched detailing. Most of their outsoles are made from Vibram with an oil-and-slip-resisting solid rubber. Boots have cushioning pads and advanced Xero Gravity Xyclone comfort insole. These boots are also waterproof.The texture and design of Cody James boots are top in quality. The grain of its leather looks like wood grain. 

Here are the main materials to know:

• Full Grain Leather: Most Cody James square toe boots are made from full grain leather. This refers to leather that has not been sanded or buffed to remove any imperfections. The natural grain remains intact, resulting in leather that is thicker and more durable. Full grain leather boots break in nicely and form to your feet over time. They also develop a beautiful patina as the natural oils rise to the surface.

• Suede Leather: Some Cody James square toe boots will use suede leather for the uppers. Suede is softer and more flexible than full grain leather. It has more texture and visual depth. Suede requires more care as it can stain and scuff easily. A suede protector spray is recommended to repel dirt and water.

• Exotic Leathers: For a luxurious upgrade, some Cody James boots incorporate small amounts of exotic leathers. This includes materials like ostrich, alligator, lizard and snake. The exotic leather is generally used as an accent in the form of an inset or piping detail. It provides added visual interest and depth.

Cody James Boots Pros and Cons

Where to Buy Cody James Boots?

Bootbarn.com

Sheplers.com

Tecovas vs. Ariat vs. Justin Boots vs. Cody James: Comparison Table 

Conclusion: Which is Best for You?

There are always five main factors to consider when buying a new pair of boots: style, material quality, construction quality, comfort, and price.Tecovas focuses on a more refined, classic Western aesthetic with high-quality materials and construction at a premium price point.It is best for someone looking for a refined, classic Western boot with a focus on quality and craftsmanship. While Ariat prioritizes performance and functionality with advanced technology.The brand is best for individuals seeking boots for active lifestyles who prioritize performance and advanced features. 

If you want a reliable, well-known brand with a diverse selection of styles at different price points, go for Justin Boots.If you prioritize premium quality, intricate designs, and are willing to pay a higher price, consider Cody James.

Frequently Asked Questions 

Is Ariat boots made in USA?

No, most Ariat boots are not made in the USA. Their primary manufacturing facilities are located in Italy, Mexico, and China, in addition to some facilities in the United States.

How long do Ariats last?

You can expect them to last at least five years — often more. Some people have shared that they wore their Ariat boots for up to 15 years!

Do Ariats run large or small?

Ariat boots tend to run a bit larger than other boots. A good rule of thumb when fitting Ariat boots is that you should order a half-size smaller than your street shoe size. The size charts reflect this recommendation, and people generally agree that the suggested sizing is appropriate.

Are Tecovas boots made in China?

Tecovas hand-crafts their boots in Leon, Mexico, which is basically the motherland of all western boots. They feature traditional cowboy boot construction methods like a Goodyear welt, traditional cording, and lemonwood pegs in the leather outsole. 

Where are Justin Boots made?

Made in the USA with Global Parts - Proudly made in the USA with global parts, the USA-Made boots are crafted by hand by the talented bootmakers at their El Paso, Texas factory.

Do Justin Boots run big or small?

Justin Boots for men and women are true to size, so I recommend ordering a pair in your normal shoe size (aside from athletic shoes) for the best fit. They should be snug yet comfortable, so you're ready to take on the day regardless of your plans.

Is Cody James owned by Boot Barn?

Yes.

Do Ariat and Justin boots fit the same?

Ariat boot sizing is similar to Justin boot sizing and many other western boot brands, so if you already have a pair of boots from Justin, you can get the same size for your Ariats.

Are Cody James boots good for work?

Absolutely! Their boots labeled as “Performance” or “Work” have comfort technology and often composite, steel or soft toes to protect your feet on the job. The durable construction holds up to heavy wear.

Are Cody James Boots Waterproof?

Not all Cody James boot styles are waterproof, but many of their boots do feature waterproof constructions that help keep feet dry in wet conditions.

【Read More】

Thursday Boots vs. Red Wing vs. Beckett Simonon vs. Tecovas: Who Wins the Boots Brand Showdown?

Carhartt vs. Carhartt WIP vs. DRI DUCK vs. Ariat: Differences and Reviews 2025

Extrabux is an international cashback shopping site, offering up to 30% cashback from 10,000+ Stores!

24S, SSENSE, MATCHESFASHION.COM, Shopbop, NET-A-PORTER, FARFETCH, YOOX, Eastbay, End Clothing, Macys, Neiman Marcus, Saks Fifth Avenue, Saks OFF 5TH, Bergdorf Goodman, Selfridges, Bloomingdales, Coggles, Harrods, Kohl's, Urban Outfitters, ASOS, Missguided, etc.

Join to get $20 welcome bonus now! (How does Welcome Bonus work?)