Revlon ColorSilk vs. Garnier Nutrisse vs. L'Oreal Excellence: Comparison and Reviews 2024

Revlon ColorSilk vs. Garnier Nutrisse vs. L'Oreal Excellence Overviews

1.Revlon ColorSilk Review 

What is Revlon ColorSilk Hair Color?

No mess, non-drip formula for easy-to-use at-home color application. The same shades and formulas loved by women are now made even better! ColorSilk Beautiful Color™ is the #1 hair color in the USA*. The ammonia-free hair color delivers 100% gray coverage and salon-quality color and shine. Achieve rich, long-lasting hair color at home! 

Hair left silky, shiny, healthy, and in better condition than before you colored it after each box. Revlon's 3D Color Gel Technology™ delivers natural-looking, multi-tonal color from root to tip, providing definition and boosting your hair's dimension.

Type: Chemical Hair Dyes | Formula: Permanent | Number of shades: 41  | Scent: Fresh | Last Time：About 3 to 4 weeks | Includes: Ammonia-free permanent hair color, developer, gloves, conditioner

Revlon ColorSilk Detail & Features 

• New, no mess, non-drip formula for best at home application

• Specially blended, permanent hair-coloring formula

• Contains 3D Color Gel Technology™, for multi-tonal results from root to tip

• Ammonia-free formula with no harsh odor

• Easy to use and no mess with precision applicator tip

• Ultra-hydrating cream conditioner highly nourishes hair after color application for optimal care and shine

• Enriched with Keratin and Silk Amino Acid

• Achieve 100% gray coverage in the comfort of your own home

• 41 natural-looking shades including shades of black, brown, blonde, red, and ultra-lights, so many beautiful colors and trend shades!

Revlon ColorSilk Pros and Cons

Office Price: $4.99@revlon.com

Where to Buy Revlon ColorSilk Hair Color?

• revlon.com

• cvs.com: up to 2% cashback

• walmart.com: up to 2% cashback

Money Saving Tip: If you like online shopping, don't forget to sign up at Extrabux！(What is Extrabux) , then you can enjoy up to 90+% cashback on your purchase from Extrabux! Sign-Up Bonus: Free to join it & get $20 welcome bonus! Student Benefits：As long as you are a student at school, you can get a free whole year long VIP Card worth $199.

Extrabux.com cooperates with many merchants, such as:Sephora（4% -5% cash back)，Dior (Up to 6% cash back), Moosejaw (5% -6% cash back), LOOKFANTASTIC (Up to 10% cash back), Microsoft (Up to 7% cash back) and so on.

How to Use It:

Everything you need is inside the box! See directions to follow all safety instructions before you begin.

• Mix : Pour ammonia-free colorant in cream developer bottle. Shake until mixture is completely blended.

• Apply : Part hair into 4 equal sections. Apply mixture to root area at each parting. Don't rub into scalp.

• Leave in : Leave the mixture on hair for 25 minutes total. For resistant gray hair, leave on for extra 10 minutes. For blonde shades, add an extra 20 minutes to total processing time.

• Rinse : Add a little warm water to hair and gently massage color mixture through hair. Rinse hair completely.

• Conditioning: Apply the ultra-hydrating cream conditioner after color application. Leave on for 3 minutes and then rinse with warm water.

2.Garnier Nutrisse Hair Color Review 

What is Garnier Nutrisse Hair Color?

Garnier Nutrisse Ultra Crème Nourishing Permanent Hair Color nourishes as it colors for 2x shinier, silkier and nourished hair vs. uncolored, unwashed hair. Garnier Nutrisse permanent black hair dye comes with a fruit oil ampoule that you pour directly into the mix. 

The nourishing after color conditioner is infused with five responsibly-sourced oils - avocado, olive, coconut, argan and shea. The new ColorBoost technology efficiently infuses intense dyes into the hair fiber for richer, radiant, and long-lasting color with 100% gray coverage. 

Garnier's non-drip color Crème adapts to all hair textures for even color with beautiful highlights. Pure pigments give you rich, shiny, accurate long-lasting hair color from root to tip. Garnier Nutrisse is cruelty free and formulated without animal derived ingredients.

Type: Permanent Hair Colors | Formula:  Creme| Number of shades:  45 | Scent:  smells great | Last Time：6 - 8 weeks | Includes: Gloves, Applicator

Garnier Nutrisse Detail & Features 

• Permanent, nourishing hair color creme with three fruit oils- avocado, olive, and shea

• The only hair color creme with a separate ampoule of grape seed oil to start nourishing as you color

• Rich, radiant, long-lasting color with 100% grey coverage

• Available in 45 Nourishing Shades

• 97% natural origin conditioner locks in color and protects against dryness

Garnier Nutrisse Pros and Cons

Office Price: $9.99 @garnierusa.com

Where to Buy Garnier Nutrisse Hair Color?

• garnierusa.com

• target.com

• walmart.com: up to 4% cashback

How to Use It:

To use Garnier Nutrisse hair color, you can follow these steps:

• Prepare: 48 hours before using the hair color, perform a skin test as directed in the kit. You can also protect your skin and hairline by applying a small amount of moisturizing cream. Put on gloves to protect your hands and clothes.

• Mix: Squeeze the colorant tube into the developer bottle and shake well.

• Apply: Start at the roots and apply the color in sections. You can use the bottle nozzle like a tail comb. Work the color into your roots with your fingers, then saturate the lengths and ends.

• Process: Leave the color on for 20 minutes for a full head application, or 25 minutes for a root touch-up. If you have resistant or coarse hair, or lots of gray hair, you can leave it on for 30 minutes.

• Rinse: Massage your hair before rinsing, then rinse thoroughly until the water runs clear.

• Condition: Apply conditioner and leave it on for 2-5 minutes, then rinse thoroughly. You can use the remaining conditioner weekly until you next color your hair.

3.L'Oreal Excellence Review 

What is L'Oreal Excellence Hair Color?

L'Oreal Paris is a well-known name in the beauty industry, and theirExcellence Hair Color is no exception. This hair color brand offers a wide variety of shades to suit every hair type and desired look. Their permanent hair color formula ensures a long-lasting, vibrant color that won't fade easily. With L'Oréal Professionnel, you can achieve stunning results and enjoy a beautiful, salon-worthy hair color that lasts.

 Introducing the New Triple Care Color routine that deeply cares for your hair, and with 100% gray hair coverage for all hair types, even on stubborn grays. The color creme is formulated with Pro-Keratine complex that protects as it colors. The new salon inspired after color shampoo is formulated specifically to be used right after rinsing out your Excellence coloring mix. It delicately cleanses the scalp and hair of excess residue. Smoothes the hair to reveal rich, radiant color.

For a less messy DIY dye experience, turn to this L'Oréal Paris kit, which was a strong performer in GH Beauty Lab testing. It ranked near the top in several areas: not being messy during application, successfully covering grays and delivering color that lasted.

Type: Permanent Hair Colors | Formula:  Permanent| Number of shades: 39 | Scent:  smells great | Last Time：up to 8 weeks | Includes: Permanent hair color cream, developer, gloves, pre-color treatment, comb applicator, conditioning treatment sample.

L'Oreal Excellence Detail & Features 

• 100% gray coverage for all hair types, even on stubborn grays.

• New Triple Care Color routine protects before, during, and after coloring for up to 8 weeks — new look, same great shades.

• New salon-inspired after-color shampoo delicately cleanses the scalp and hair by gently rinsing away excess residue.

• Salon-inspired after-color shampoo smooths the hair to reveal its radiance.

• Rich, radiant hair color from root to tip with exclusive non-drip creme formula.

L'Oreal Excellence Pros and Cons

Office Price: $10.99 @lorealparisusa.com

Where to Buy L'Oreal Excellence Hair Color?

• lorealparisusa.com

• sallybeauty.com: up to 4% cashback

• walgreens.com: up to 4% cashback

How to Use It:

Each box dye shade and variation has its own instructions so make sure you read the instructions TWICE.

• Mix the Protective Coloring Cream with the Cream Developer and shake. Apply mix on roots first, then the lengths. Massage hair afterwards and wait 30 minutes, then rinse.

• Apply the Caring Gentle pH Shampoo from the kit and rinse.

• Apply Nourishing Radiance Mask, wait for 3 minutes, rinse your hair and dry.

Conclusion: Which Hair Dye is Better?

Choosing the right professional hair color brand is crucial for achieving stunning results. From perfect grey coverage to vibrant toning, each brand offers unique benefits.

• Revlon ColorSilk Hair Color 

Best Value At-Home Hair Color

Revlon’s ammonia-free boxed hair color came out near its pricier competition in terms of performance in testing. Despite its low cost, it earned the highest scores in numerous categories. Testers gave this drugstore dye top marks for having clear instructions, being simple to prepare and rinse out, having a minimal aroma, and making hair appear smooth and shiny.

According to Revlon, the formula delivers 100% gray coverage and has keratin and silk amino acids that condition your hair for silky, shiny results. beauty favorite, the 3D color technology gives you the freedom to dye your hair at home for true multi-tonal color.

Take note, though, that it wasn’t the best at covering grays compared to other formulas and some users needed more than one box to cover their hair. 

• Garnier Nutrisse Hair Color 

Best At-Home Hair Color

Garnier's permanent color is made with no ammonia and a high concentration of nourishing oil so it's gentle on hair that's damaged from treatments like keratin or thinning strands. The formula scored high for its pleasant non-chemical scent, ease of rinsing and not irritating, and it didn't fade over weeks after application.

The Garnier Nutrisse Hair Color Line is really great for people who have been dying their hair for years, as well as beginners. Each box comes with clear directions and even plastic gloves. Their website has a bunch of tutorial videos teaching and demonstrating different dyeing techniques. They even have a “Shade Selector” on their website which helps their customers find the perfect shade for their hair needs. 

However, it didn't perform as well as others at increasing hair's shine, though.

•  L'Oreal Excellence Hair Color 

Best Non-Messy At-Home Hair Color

L'Oréal Paris Excellence Créme Permanent Hair Color provides natural-looking coverage that's easy to apply. It's also really affordable and easily found in many drugstores.

It's available in a wide range of shades from very natural to a little bit out there, it includes not just a single-tip applicator but also comes with a comb applicator that makes it a breeze to color the hair fringing my face, it doesn't run or drip, it does a great job of covering my gray, and it doesn't smell too bad. The kit also includes a pre-color moisturizer that helps the color absorb evenly from roots to ends.

For a less messy DIY dye experience, turn to this L'Oréal Paris kit, which ranked near the top in several areas: not being messy during application, successfully covering grays and delivering color that lasted.

Some drawbacks included that it didn't score well for fade resistance in Lab assessments or with consumer testers for leaving hair looking smooth. 

Summarize：

If you are to decide on any of these three brands products, it is best to consider your hair type. So Revlon ColorSilk vs. Garnier Nutrisse vs. L'Oreal Excellence Hair Color, Which one Is Best for You? How  Can I Choose?

• Garnier is a branch of the L'Oreal cosmetics company, but a significant difference exists in the price and quantity of the product. Garnier and L'Oreal differ in appearance, but some products are similar in composition. 

• They have different qualities and factors - Garnier products are easy to use, and for L'Oreal, you will need the instruction manual; Garnier  is very cheap and L'Oreal is more expensive.

So, L'Oreal Excellence hair color  is a little more expensive, but a lot of women are happy to buy it because of its existence from Garnier's hair color.

• Garnier is good for regular use, and L'Oreal is used for special purposes; Garnier hair colors have the highest overlap strength and flush the least.

• Revlon ColorSilk is a permanent hair colour kit that works to provide high quality, professional hair dye results at home. The formula features Revlon 3D ColourGel Technology™ to deliver natural-looking, multi-tonal colour from root to tip.

The problem with Revlon ColorSilk  is the after-color conditioner that they give you is not very good. This could be why you think it`s damaging your hair. If you follow it with a good quality salon conditioner, that should be fine.

Both L`Oreal and Revlon make excellent colors. But L`Oreal color lasts a little longer, give you hair a bit more shine and their conditioners are a little better. Keep in mind their colors cost more than Revlon ColorSilk  do.

FAQs

1.Do I need to shampoo before I color?

Do not shampoo immediately before coloring unless hair is heavily soiled. Wait at least 24 hours between shampooing and coloring.

2.Will permanent haircolor lighten another permanent haircolor?

Do not use a lighter hair color product in an attempt to correct your darker hair color results. Hair color products cannot lift or lighten a previously dyed hair color. Using more color will only make the hair darker.

3.How often should I dye my hair to cover gray?

Because gray hairs can be so sneaky, maintaining a lapse-less hair color schedule is probably the most important part of managing them. 

How often you’ll need to come back depends on the difference between your natural shade and the salon color, as well as the technique your stylist uses. It’ll be a little bit different for everybody, but certainly not an opportunity to walk away for six months at a time.

4.Can Hair Color be Used on Sensitive Scalps?

Yes, professional hair color brands often offer options specifically formulated for sensitive scalps. These products are typically hypoallergenic and tested by dermatologists to ensure they are safe for use on sensitive skin. It is always recommended to do a patch test before applying any hair color to check for any adverse reactions.

5.What is a good hair dye to use at home?

If you want something more long-lasting, you can try demi-permanent, semi-permanent, or permanent color. Just know that most colorists will recommend ammonia-free or low ammonia formulas since they tend to be the gentlest on hair.

6.What type of hair dye lasts the longest?

Permanent hair dyes last the longest. As previously mentioned, permanent hair dye penetrates through the hair shaft, causing the color to be permanently absorbed into your hair. Semi-permanent dyes will be stripped away over time by shampoo. 

Read More:

Top 17 Drugstore Hair Dyes for Asian Hair in 2024

Top 16 Best Hair Oils for Asian Hair 2024

25 Popular Highlights Ideas for Asian Hair in 2024

28 Popular Hair Color Ideas for Asian Tan Skin in 2024

13 Best Permanent Hair Dyes for Dark Hair without Bleach 2024

12 Best Professional Hair Color to Cover Gray for Brunettes 2024

15 Best Hair Dyes for Brown Hair with Highlights in 2024

25 Popular Hair Color Ideas for Asian Skin Tones in 2024

20 Popular Hair Color Ideas for Asian Men in 2024

Top 15 Best Shampoos and Conditioners for Asian Hair 2024

Top 15 Best Dry Shampoos and Conditioners for Asian Hair 2024

Top 15 Korean Shampoos and Conditioners for Hair Loss 2024

L'oreal Hair Color vs. Garnier vs. Clairol: Which Brand Is Best for You?

Redken vs. Pureology vs. Olaplex vs. Biolage: Which One Wins the Salon-Quality Haircare Brand Showdown?

K18 Hair Mask vs. Olaplex No.3 vs. Living Proof Triple Bond Complex: Comparison and Reviews 2024

Extrabux is an international cashback shopping site, offering up to 30% cashback from 10,000+ Stores!

LOOKFANTASTIC, SkinStore, SkinCareRx, Feelunique, Cult Beauty, Sephora, Belk, Estee Lauder, Lancome, La Mer, Kiehl's, Clinique, Elizabeth Arden, Adore Beauty, Sol de Janeiro, Hourglass, Lancer, Shiseido, FOREO, Macy's, etc.

Join to get $20 welcome bonus now! (How does Welcome Bonus work?)