Darn Tough vs. Smartwool vs. Bombas vs. icebreaker: Which One Wins the Socks Brand Showdown?
- Socks are something we pull out and pull on each day without hardly even thinking about it.
- Whether it’s a hike in the forest, climbing rugged mountains, or strolling along the shores of a lake, there are certain things you should always take with you. One of those essential items is comfy, durable socks amd Merino wool has always been a top choice to weather any condition. Nowsdays, when it comes to the best of merino wool socks, it always boils down to four brands: Darn Tough, Smartwool, Bombas and icebreaker! But are they the best wool socks for hiking? Or the best wool socks for working out? Or the best wool socks to wear all the time? Read on and we’re going to be looking at Darn Tough vs. Smartwool vs. Bombas vs. icebreaker socks to see which of these four popular brands offers you more value for your money by comparing the history, pros and cons of each, comfort and materials, performance and value and so on...
Cover Photo:darntough.com
Darn Tough
History and Origin
Darn Tough is based out of Vermont, USA, and the brand of Cabot Hosiery Mills (wiki) – a family business started in 1978 who used to manufacture socks for larger brands like GAP. In 2004 they took it into their own hands to sell socks designed for durability under their own label.
All manufacturing is still done in Vermont and here are links to their sustainability & sourcing ethos. They seem to use 100% RWS-certified wool, primarily sourced from South Africa, New Zealand, Uruguay and Argentina.
What Are Darn Tough Socks?
Darn Tough socks are made from merino wool, nylon, and Lycra. This combination of materials makes them particularly adept at temperature regulation and moisture-wicking — two factors that can help you avoid blisters or foot injuries.
Darn Tough socks can be worn for any purpose, but are particularly beloved for running, hiking, snow sports, and other technical or outdoor activities.
The company makes men's, women's, unisex, and kids' socks with different thicknesses, calf heights, and designs. Usually, you pick based on the weather you're heading out in or the activity you're doing.
Darn Tough Socks Reviews
Pros | Cons |
|
|
Where to Buy Darn Tough Socks Cheapest?
backcountry.com: 3 - 4% cashback
Money Saving Tip:
If you like online shopping, don't forget to sign up at Extrabux!(What is Extrabux) , then you can enjoy up to 30+% cashback on your purchase from Extrabux! Sign-Up Bonus: Free to join it & get $20 welcome bonus! Student Benefits:As long as you are a student at school, you can get a free whole year long VIP Card worth $199.
Extrabux.com cooperates with many merchants, such as: Walmart (Up to 4% cashback), Sephora(4% -5% cash back),Dior (Up to 6% cash back), Moosejaw (5% -6% cash back), LOOKFANTASTIC (Up to 10% cash back), Microsoft (Up to 7% cash back) and so on.
Who Are Darn Tough socks for?
Anyone struggling with cold or sweaty feet.
Folks with poor circulation
high impact sports
hiking
tough work environments
casual
extreme climates- Merino wool does great in temperature extremes and wet environments.
2 Best Darn Tough Socks
# Darn Tough Women's No Show Tab Ultra-Lightweight with Cushion Run Sock
Price: $14.41 - $24.94 @ Amazon
A top choice for an athletics and fitness sock. They’re durable, light, low cut, and stay cool throughout your workout routine.
# Darn Tough Men's No Show Tab Ultra-Lightweight Run Sock
Price: $15.95 - $20.07 @ Amazon
A great choice for hot weather athletics. Light, understated, and the merino wool will wick away sweat to help you stay remarkably odour free.
Smartwool
History and Origin
Smartwool (wiki) was founded in Colorado, USA, in 1994, but purchased by VF Corporation in 2011, who also owns brands like North Face, Supreme, icebreaker, Vans and more. Smartwool is focused on being an outdoor activities type brand.
In 2010, Smartwool signed a contract to exclusively source its Merino wool from the New Zealand Merino Company. Smartwool now uses merino wool sourced from China and other as yet undisclosed sources. It also has moved to a blended yarn to improve durability.
What Are Smartwool Socks ?
Smartwool is one of the most well-known and respected brands in the market. These socks are made from merino wool from sheep bred in New Zealand. New Zealand merino wool is known for being some of the softest and most luxurious.
Smartwool uses merino wool as their primary fabric, a high-performance, natural fibre. What’s more, the high-quality construction means comfort and durability are guaranteed in every pair. Finally, the brand offers a range of activity-specific socks that provide optimised performance.
Smartwool socks come in a variety of cushioning weights, ranging from ultralight to extra heavy. The latter provides more support and warmth, while the former is lightweight and fast-drying. This is something to consider in light of your natural body temperature and the choice of activity.
Smartwool Socks Review
Pros | Cons |
|
|
Where to Buy Smartwool Socks Cheapest?
smartwool.com: 3 - 4 % cashback
moosejaw.com: 8 -10 % cashback
ems.com(Eastern Mountain Sports): 4- 5% cashback
Who Are Smartwool Socks for?
Walkers
Hikers
Cyclists
Runners
Streetballers
Strollers
Wayfarers
Pedestrians
2 Best Smartwool Socks
# Performance Hike Light Cushion Crew Socks
Price: $24 @ SmartWool
The 7” tall Performance Hike Light Cushion Crew Socks are a versatile and dependable hiking companion for all your adventures. The proprietary Indestructawool technology combines a uniquely strong construction with extended durability zones in high-friction areas, such as the arch, ankle, and sole.
# Athletic Targeted Cushion Stripe Crew Socks
Price: $10.08 @ SmartWool
At the intersection of comfort and performance you’ll find the Athletic Targeted Cushion Stripe Crew Socks. These are designed for daily use among highly active people. The merino-blend construction ensures odours are kept at minimum and moisture is continually wicked, leaving your feet feeling fresh all day long.
Bombas
History and Origin
Bombas is a sustainable company that makes socks, t-shirts, and underwear—but mostly socks. The brand is a Certified B Corp, meaning it scores well in terms of environmentally friendly material sourcing, ethical production, employee treatment, and transparency.
It all started in 2013 when its founders learned that the most requested item in homeless shelters is socks. To address that need, for every pair of Bombas socks sold, the brand donates a pair to a homeless shelter. Since then, a pair of specially crafted socks is donated to a homeless shelter in need for every pair sold, which now totals over 50 million donated items!
What Are Bombas Socks?
High quality construction and detailed design are the two major factors that make Bombas different and better than other socks. While the brand has common styles like crew, calf, and ankle socks, you'll also find heavyweight wool hiking socks, lightweight running socks, dress socks, tennis socks, grippy socks, and so much more.
Regardless of which style you choose, Bombas is known for its proprietary Honeycomb Arch Support System. The technology cradles the arch of your foot for a snug, yet comfortable fit. It also helps to prevent your socks from losing shape after a few wears and washes. Every pair of Bombas socks also has a seamless toe and a Y-Stitched Heel, which creates a natural cup around your heel to prevent slippage.
Other useful design features include blister tabs on its ankle socks, thoughtfully placed tension, or "Stay-Up technology" on calf socks, and a combination of heel grips and contoured seams on no-shows.
Bombas Socks Review
Pros | Cons |
|
|
Where to Buy Bombas Socks Cheapest?
saksfifthavenue.com:1.5 - 2% cashback
qvc.com: 3 - 4% cashback
Who Are Bombas Socks for?
Cycling
Running
Weightlifting
Barre
Pilates
Yoga
Tennis
Golfing
2 Best Bombas Socks
# Bombas Performance Running Socks
Price: $16.50 - $18 @ Bombas
If you’re looking to up (or start!) your running game, it’s hard to go wrong with Bombas’ Performance running socks. Not only are they supportive, secure and moisture-wicking—as all good athletic socks should be—they’re just plain comfortable.
# Bombas Women’s Hiking Calf Sock 3-Pack
Price: $54 @ Bombas
These calf hiking socks are specifically designed for maximum hiking comfort. The socks use Hex Tec technology, which helps ventilate and regulate your feet’s temperature no matter what the outside temperature is. Combined with the moisture-wicking fabric blend, your feet (and calves!) will stay cool in the summer, warm in the winter, and dry year-round.
Icebreaker
History and Origin
Icebreaker is a merino wool outdoor and natural performance outdoor clothing brand headquartered in Auckland, New Zealand. It was purchased by VF Corporation, a NYSE listed entity in 2018. Icebreaker was conceived and designed around the philosophy of sustainability, using natural fibres, environmental and social ethics, and animal welfare. The company began by specialising in the creation of merino base layers and now offers underwear, mid layers, outer wear, socks and accessories based on natural fibers.
Icebreaker was founded in 1995 by Jeremy Moon, and now supplies its clothing to more than 4,700 stores in 50 countries.
What Are Icebreaker Socks?
These lightweight, breathable merino wool socks from Icebreaker are perfect for your warm-weather hiking and backpacking trips. Thanks to the natural properties of wool, they're odour-resistant and highly moisture-wicking.
Don't underestimate the functionality of Icebreaker's sustainable merino wool socks. They are moisture-wicking, durable, odour-resistant and engineered to have a premium fit. Shop Icebreaker socks for all activities including hiking, snow, running and training.
Icebreaker Socks Review
Pros | Cons |
|
|
Where to Buy Icebreaker Socks Cheapest?
icebreaker.com: 4 - 5% cashback
backcountry.com: 3 - 4% cashback
wiggle.com:1.5 - 2% cashback
Who Are Icebreaker Socks for?
Biking
Running
Hiking
Other high intensity sports
2 Best Icebreaker Socks
# Icebreaker Hike+ Medium Crew Socks
Price: $25 @ Icebreaker
Lightweight, durable, odor-resisting trail socks that deliver maximum comfort and a premium fit, the men's Icebreaker Hike+ Medium Crew socks are ideal for day hiking in warmer conditions.
# Icebreaker Run+ Ultralight Micro Socks
Price: $18 @ Icebreaker
Thin and ultralight, the men's Icebreaker Run+ Ultralight Micro running socks are built with a technical merino wool blend in a no-show height, making them perfect for runs of any mileage.
Darn Tough vs. Smartwool vs. Bombas vs. icebreaker: Comparison Side by Side
1.Comfort and Materials
Darn Tough Socks
Overall, really good and during daily wear we did not amazed – the hiking socks were too thick and the sport socks were too thin. The material is also a little ‘rough’ compared to others, but not at all a disturbance.
However, in active cases, the Darn Tough socks were excellent with no slippage, good foot design, and overall, we rate them a B+ in the comfort department.
Smartwool Socks
Smartwool regains points here because we really felt like these were excellent both when doing casual stuff & active things. They held on perfectly for sports, never got swampy, and were great for even sitting around all day.
Great footbox, comfortable material, just the right thickness and breathability. Excellent for all-around use and we rate them an A in this section.
Bombas Socks
Bombas performance socks contain Hex Tec technology that’s breathable and moisture-wicking, for added airflow and comfort while you’re working out.
These socks definitely feel tighter and heavier than regular socks, so they can get warm during the day, but the extra material seems to hold everything in place, making them excellent for workouts and activities of all kinds.
Icebreaker Socks
We found the Icebreaker socks to be very comfy and soft from the get go and are terrific for casual use, but quickly lost their edge when it came to activities & sports due to slippage and almost clamminess.
They felt too ‘thick’ or fluffy when the going got rough and just didn’t have the right feeling for hiking & running. Footbox is great though over overall they get a B+ for comfort.
2.Performance
Darn Tough Socks
With a thinly cushioned, durable, comfortable sock, you can do just about anything. The Darn Tough Socks can handle virtually any climate or weather condition, because it dries so quickly.
Smartwool Socks
Merino wool is a renowned moisture-regulating fabric, meaning that though you will sweat in a Smartwool sock, rarely ever will you drench them. Especially during high activity, the Smartwool socks are comfortable, soft, and generally warm enough, but not excessively padded.
Bombas Socks
Unlike their more basic socks, Bombas performance socks are made with Seamless Toe technology for front-of-foot support, have strategic zone cushioning for the arch, toes, ankle, etc, and a Y-stitched heel for a tailored fit that won’t move.
Icebreaker Socks
Based on the fit of the sock, you can really tell that Icebreaker put a lot of effort and attention to detail into making the sock fit your foot perfectly. The heel area has a unique shape that almost juts out of the rest of the sock to fit snugly on your heel. The toe area has a special toe seam prevents chafing and the main elastic band fits just below the ankle.
3.Value
Darn Tough Socks
Made in America, comfortable, cozy, durably made with a lifetime guarantee.
If you can put a price on that, Darn Tough says it’s about the price of two cocktails, they run anywhere from $15 – $30+ for their socks.
Smartwool Socks
Cool colors and patterns, versatility and the reliability of the tried-and-tested Smartwool brand.
Still, the long term durability does not compete with it’s competitor Darn Tough, which can be found for cheaper basically anywhere. However, There are plenty of Smartwool socks on sale!
Bombas Socks
They were expensive, but they will last. After six weeks of wearing the same 5 pairs every week, I’m confident you’ll find them worth the investment, and you might even save money in the long run through having to buy socks less often.
Icebreaker Socks
While the socks are made of merino wool, they aren’t completely wool. The Icebreaker socks are a great option for travelers due to it’s weight and comfort but with some limitations in terms of durability.
4.Warranty
Darn Tough Socks
Darn Tough’s warrantee is truly insane. No one in the clothing industry dares to go as far as they do.In fact, Darn Tough’s Guarantee is more like an insurance policy than a warrantee.
It reads in part:
“Our unconditional lifetime guarantee is simple and without strings or conditions. If our socks are not the most comfortable, durable and best fitting socks you have ever owned, return them for another pair.”
Smartwool Socks
They have a fairly decent policy which is a pretty standard 100% satisfaction guaranteed form.
Items can also be sent in to be recycled you can also send it into their service centre.
Bombas Socks
Bombas also has a happiness guarantee, here’s what they say:
"Our priority here at Bombas is your happiness. Which means we stand by our product 100%, no matter what, no questions asked, no holds barred, no ifs, no ands, no buts. If you have a problem, we will solve it. Refund it. Send you new socks. Whatever it takes. Just reach out to our Customer Happiness Team. We’re here for you. Happiness. Guaranteed."
Icebreaker Socks
They will assess the damage on a case-by-case basis to determine if your warranty is eligible. In addition, Icebreaker has a lifetime warranty on all of its socks.
You’ll have to fill out any warranty claims on their website to be considered.
Conclusion: Which Brand is Best for You?
To summarize,all Darn Tough, Smartwool, Bombas and icebreaker are great brands for socks as this post has mentioned, and we have outlined the pros and cons of both these well-regarded brands.
However, if you are still unsure, we have briefly summarised the main advantages of each below.
Darn Tough Socks
(1)Darn Tough socks check all the boxes of a really, really stellar product: They perform their function perfectly to keep your feet comforted, dry, and blister-free;
(2)They are totally worth the premium price tag, especially for tactical needs like hiking and snow sports, where their ability to keep your feet warm and dry is crucial.
(2)They are made sustainably and locally from a small business; and offer a lifetime guarantee.
Smartwool Socks
(1)Comfort Matters - In terms of pure comfort, no sock beats Smartwool. The premium shearling insulation keeps Smartwool socks soft to the touch. Against the skin of the foot, Smartwool socks feel almost luxurious.
(2)No More Stinky Feet - Smartwool socks breathe, which allows perspiration to escape and keeps your feet dry. And a dry foot is a foot that isn't smelly.
(3)Smartwool Socks Aren't Just for Hiking - They make superb "around the house" socks too, especially during colder weather.
Bombas Socks
(1)Bombas might be more expensive than most socks brands, but between the quality, comfort, durability, and the philanthropic efforts of the company, they're well worth adding to your drawer.
(2)If you’re looking to up (or start!) your running game, it’s hard to go wrong with Bombas’ Performance running socks. Not only are they supportive, secure and moisture-wicking—as all good athletic socks should be—they’re just plain comfortable.
(3)Whether you’re an avid runner looking for an edge, someone who leads a generally active life, or just someone who likes great socks, Bombas’ Performance Running Socks will treat you well.
Icebreaker Socks
(1)Icebreaker socks were among the softest we tested, and they were also the only pair that fit anatomically. That means better breathability, with more space around your foot in the boot.
(2)All about style and leaving it simple. Modern, minimalist, classic, non-offensive, and basic. Meant to pair well with jeans, shorts, a suit, or running shoes.
(3)Note that these socks showed signs of wear more quickly than the other models we tested—but like the rest of our picks, Icebreaker’s socks come with a lifetime guarantee.
Summary:
So yeah, Darn Toughs for a darn tough work/hiking sock, Smartwool for sports, hiking & lifestyle ventures,Bombas for avid runner looking for an edge, or just someone who likes great socks, and Icebreaker for the casual dailywear person.
Read More:
UGG Mini vs. Ultra Mini vs. Mini II: Differences and Reviews 2024
New Balance 860 vs. 880 vs. 890 vs. 1080: Differences and Reviews 2024
Golden Goose vs. Veja vs. Common Projects vs. Vintage Havana: Which Brand is the Best?
Balenciaga Triple S vs. Track vs. Gucci Rhyton: Which One is the Best Dad Shoes to Choose in 2024?
Nike Air Jordan 1 vs. Air Force 1 vs. Nike Dunk: What are the Differences?
Extrabux is an international cashback shopping site, offering up to 30% cashback from 10,000+ Stores!
24S, SSENSE, MATCHESFASHION.COM, Shopbop, NET-A-PORTER, FARFETCH, YOOX, Eastbay, End Clothing, Macys, Neiman Marcus, Saks Fifth Avenue, Saks OFF 5TH, Bergdorf Goodman, Selfridges, Bloomingdales, Coggles, Harrods, Kohl's, Urban Outfitters, ASOS, Missguided, etc.
Join to get $20 welcome bonus now! (How does Welcome Bonus work?)
Recommendation
-
Is Turkish Airlines Good for International Flights?
-
10 Best & Stylish Winter Coats for Women on NET-A-PORTER in 2024
-
Top & Best 12 Sneaker Apps/Websites for Raffles, Releases & Restocks in 2024
-
7 Best Gift Card Exchange Sites - Buy, Sell and Trade Discount Gift Card Safely and Instanly!
-
Top 9 Professional Skincare Brands for Licensed Estheticians 2024