Tiffany vs. Cartier vs. Bvlgari Engagement Rings: Which Brand is the Best? (History, Quality, Design & Price)

History for The Three Jewelry Brands

The Story of Tiffany

Founded in 1837 by Charles Lewis Tiffany and John B. Young, Tiffany was originally named Tiffany & Young. They were the first company to bring gemstones to the USA, after buying jewellery from French aristocrats fleeing France in 1848 during the revolution. By 1853, Charles Tiffany assumed control of the company and renamed it Tiffany & Co.And it is one of the internationally-recognized brands for fine and luxury jewelry. Having been on the market for a number of decades, you can find pretty much any kind of wedding band or other kinds of fine jewelry from Tiffany’s.

Now, while Cartier dates back to 1847, Tiffany is a few years younger than Cartier, and the Tiffany Setting dates back to 1886 when Tiffany &Co. founder Charles Lewis Tiffany had the vision to create a ring that would highlight the beauty of the brilliant-cut diamonds by Tiffany’s. Thanks to his vision, and after 130+ years, Tiffany Setting engagement rings remain the company’s and also the world’s most desirable and popular engagement ring.

Tiffany is known for its wide range of superior-quality wedding bands that luxuriate and boast a superior level of craftsmanship.Tiffany’s engagement rings often stand out because of Tiffany’s proprietary Tiffany Setting, which is considered the most famous type of engagement rings designs in the world. 

>>Click here to buy Tiffany

Pros and cons of Tiffany engagement ring

Pros:

• Unique Tiffany Setting。

• Excellent packaging with in-house ring certificate and two jewelry pouches.

• Tiffany boasts a huge foreign influence, and it’s doing really well in markets across the Asia Pacific, as well as a large part of Europe, and North America, hence more affordable prices.

• You avoid sales tax when you buy online.

• The Tiffany Experience is breathtaking, and second-to-none.
  

Cons:

• Expensive, and you often pay for marketing.

• The rings could be cheaper.

• Not GIA-certified.

• Limited selection.

The Story of Cartier

Cartier was founded in 1847 in Paris by the jeweller Louis-François Cartier, who in 1899 handed over to his three sons.Cartier is one of the oldest luxury jewelry brands on the market, but it’s also a very regal brand. Cartier is known for its exceptional designs and the matching level of workmanship behind their jewelry designs, which is why Cartier continues to hold the top spot as the leading wedding ring designer.

In 1899, Cartier opened its boutique on the Rue de la Paix in Paris.  It was a true luxury shopping experience, with plush carpets and beautifully finished glass cabinets that displayed the jewellery to its full advantage.

Cartier was eventually taken international with offices in New York and London, and in 1904, it was awarded the Royal Warrant and became the jewellery supplier of the Royal Court of England.

In 1910, Cartier acquired the Hope Diamond, which had been in French hands since 1668. The diamond is widely regarded as one of the most beautiful diamonds in the world, and also one of the most famous.

The Cartier family retained ownership of the firm until 1964. It is now part of the Richemont Group.

Today, it boasts a long, prestigious history with some of the best fine jewelry and watches collections. What you may not know is that Cartier is the jewelry house that pioneered the use of platinum in jewelry, which is why the company is highly regarded by most people.

Cartier is behind breathtaking wedding bands collections that ooze luxury and fabulousness, especially with their famous Cartier diamond wedding ring collections.

>>Click here to buy Cartier

Pros and cons of Cartier engagement ring

Pros:

• Exquisite craftsmanship.

• Beautiful rings.

• Free-ring cleaning services.

• Free resizing within 3 months of buying the ring.

• Exquisite packaging.

• Handpicked diamonds.

Cons:

• There are limited choices of diamonds to choose from.

• The ring sizes are limited and constrained, with the free resizing service available only within the first 3 months of ring purchase.

• Shopping online isn’t easy with fewer specifications provided.

• The rings are expensive.

• Cartier doesn’t cut or produce their diamonds; they only handpick them.

The Story of Bvlgari

Founded in Rome in 1884 by the talented Greek silversmith Sotirio Bulgari, the brand quickly established a reputation for Italian excellence with exquisite craftsmanship and magnificent jewellery creations. Over the decades, the Bulgari generations defined a distinctive style made of vibrant colour combinations, exquisitely balanced volumes and unmistakable motifs that pay homage to the Roman roots of the company. While always revering its cultural legacy, Bulgari introduced innovations that rewrote the rules of the jewellery universe and launched new trends that stood out as icons of contemporary design.

Necklace in gold with emerald, rubies and diamonds, 1969.The detachable octagonal pendant can be worn as a brooch and is set with a 44,60 cts. cabochon emerald in a frame of rubies and brilliant-cut diamonds. The geometrical shape is an hallmark of the Bvlgari style, inspired by the monuments and decorative motifs of the Eternal City.

In the 1980s and 1990s, Bvlgari continued to innovate and launched distinctive, versatile jewels designed to be worn from morning until night. Modular jewellery was the answer for any woman’s need: a single element with a strong design was the starting point to be replicated and combined with a wide range of precious stones, from hematite to coral to diamond pave.

>>Click here to buy Bvlgari 

Pros and cons of Bvlgar engagement ring

Pros:

• ulgari engagement rings come in a range of styles.

• GIA certified diamonds. 

• Bulgari engagement rings can easily be paired with their matching designer wedding bands, many of which feature scatter set diamonds or unique designs.

Cons:

• Expensive.

Saving Tip:  If you like online shopping,don't forget to sign up at Extrabux.com！(What is Extrabux),then you can enjoy up to 30%+ cashback on your order from Extrabux! Sign-Up Bonus: Free to join it & get $20 welcome bonus!  

Other Best Places to Buy Engagement Rings Online:

• Zales: 4% Super Cash Back

• Ritani: Up to 4% Super Cash Back

• Blue Nile: 5% Super Cash Back

• Kay Jewelers: Up to 4% Super Cash Back

Differences Between Tiffany, Bvlgari & Cartier

1.Price

Tiffany - The cost of a brand new Tiffany engagement rings can start at $1,500 with extravagant rings costing well over $15,000. The exact cost of a Tiffany engagement ring depends on size and quality of the ring’s center stone as well as the complexity of the setting.

Cartier - The average price for a Cartier engagement rings from a little under $1500 to over $25,000 for the diamond engagement rings.

Bvlgari - The average price for a Bvlgari engagement rings from a little under $700 to over $75,000 for the diamond engagement rings.

2.Quality

Tiffany - Although the company boasts the production of high-quality engagement rings,Tiffany uses more of sterling silver.But Tiffany engagement rings can feature an array of gemstones such as diamonds, sapphires and tanzanite. Using only the highest quality gemstones in their creations, these are sourced from exceptional raw materials. Diamonds, for instance, are always Excellent cuts, have great color and clarity grades and never have strong fluorescence. All engagement rings come with either a Tiffany Diamond certificate or GIA certificate, to illustrate the exceptional quality of their engagement rings. 

Cartier - Cartier engagement rings are made of 95% platinum, and the 5% is a mix of metals that often include ruthenium, iridium, and/or palladium. This composition leaves you with a heavy and high-quality engagement rings.Cartier selects diamonds very carefully, choosing only stones with no visible inclusions and colorless diamond color ratings. Stones are also carefully examined for symmetry and brilliance to create the perfect ring.

Bvlgari - With particular attention to sleek, contemporary styles, Bulgari engagement rings are widely known for their high quality. All diamonds used in Bulgari designs are colorless and are independently evaluated by the Gemological Institute of America, making all of them GIA certified diamonds.

3.Styles

Tiffany - Tiffany’s engagement rings are beautiful, but the designs are not as complicated.The classic Tiffany engagement ring exudes simplistic elegance. Discover classic and contemporary styles and settings, from traditional solitaire engagement rings to modern pavé and halo designs—all made with unparalleled craftsmanshipYou know your product has reached the top of the tree when the world is littered with lookalikes sold as ‘Tiffany style’. This exclusivity comes at a price and the price of wearing this most famous of rings is out of the reach of many.

Cartier - Cartier engagement rings come in both classic styles and modern designs. Classic diamond solitaire engagement rings may use multiple accent stones or pave settings for added brilliance, while bezel, prong, and channel engagement ring settings are other popular choices.Cartier's contemporary engagement rings are exquisite masterpieces of gemological artistry. When designing a new ring, modern trends and historic heritage are blended together for a unique ring with a hint of traditional flair. Elaborate channel settings in swirls and geometric patterns are reminiscent of art deco engagement rings, while the different sizes of accent stones add textural interest and distinction to the piece. 

For any new design, balance is key - the ring must not look lopsided or disproportionate in any way. Furthermore, Cartier jewelers take care that the diamond setting is as beautiful upside down as it is when worn, guaranteeing that the ring is always viewed at its best.

Bvlgari - Bulgari has a unique style: not quite vintage, but not quite modern either. Instead, each ring is a sophisticated combination of traditional diamond mystique and a hint of romance with a generous measure of contemporary flair. Bulgari engagement rings come in a range of styles.

Within the different Bulgari ring collections, various diamond shapes are used, including round, emerald, oval, and pear shapes. While the classic prong tiffany settings are the most popular, many rings feature channel-set accents and several rings also use bezel settings. Different precious metals are also used, including platinum, white gold, and yellow gold, though a limited number of designs also use rose gold.

4.Service

Tiffany - Tiffany offers a range of lifetime services with the purchase of your Tiffany diamond engagement ring, including ring sizing, polishing and routinely checking the security of your setting. And the Ring Upgrade Program offers the opportunity to upgrade your Tiffany engagement ring. From designing unique engagement rings with custom Blue Boxes to personalizing engravable wedding bands, Diamond Experts will work with you to create a unique symbol of your love.

Cartier - Cartier offers free Gift Wrapping and Red Cartier carrier bag. It is a complimentary service that seals your package using a pre-molded wax and hand-stamp that gives it a vintage look.  Cartier also features complimentary standard shipping and return shipping for all online orders within 30 days of purchase.

The jewelry retailer provides free ring re-sizing for 3 months. There are limitations, however, as some rings have restrictions as to how much they can be altered. They also provide free cleaning services to your engagement rings. Cartier has quite a robust list of services that require a workmanship fee including shining, polishing, re-sizing, restoration, reproduction & pairing (when a piece of jewelry is impossible to repair Cartier will remake a new piece using material from the old), engraving and transformation.

Bvlgari - 1.Cleaning and polishing services.2.Your Bulgari jewel can be personalized by engraving a name, a date or a message on the precious metal (service subject to technical constraints and space availability). 3.Re-sizing Service:Performed on a bracelet, necklace, chain or ring, this service consists of increasing or reducing the size of the item within limitations and without affecting its aesthetic, comfort and quality. 4.Repair service.

Tiffany vs. Bvlgarivs vs. Cartier: Which is Better?

Bvlgari,Cartier and Tiffany are luxury jewelry brands with a worldwide presence.Their wedding bands offer an enduring appeal, and both make perfect choices of wedding bands.

Cartier is the crown jewel of eccentric high-end jewelry, including watches and the best of engagement rings, and though imperfectly expensive, Cartier wins in terms of the quality of the products they offer.

But if you are on a slightly smaller budget, then Tiffany would be a good fit.Tiffany is a more recognizable and very popular jewelry brand.

Couples interested in a sleek, contemporary style with uncompromising quality and elegance need look no further than Bulgari engagement rings. These designer creations are sophisticated yet mystical, offering all the intrigue and romance of a classic engagement ring with a unique modern twist.

The decision to choose one company over the other will, however, depend on several factors, including your budget and the uniqueness of the ring.

The 2 Most Popular Engagement Rings Settings

1.Tiffany Setting Engagement Rings

When Tiffany introduced the multi-pronged Tiffany Setting in 1886, it was a complete paradigm shift in engagement ring styles. Tiffany’s breakthrough setting held the diamond up above the band and effectively maximized the amount of light that could pass through it and, in turn, the diamond’s brilliance.

Since then, the Tiffany Setting remains the quintessential modern engagement ring and perhaps the most popular engagement ring style overall.

2.Solitaire 1895 from Cartier

A Cartier staple for over a century, the Solitaire 1895 ring has withstood the test of time. A trademark setting of four prongs and a basket illuminates the power of the diamond, resulting in a symbol of commitment that surpasses a lifetime.

The classic Solitaire 1895 ring features a brilliant-cut diamond, set high in four prongs to maximize the stone’s brilliance, similar to the aforementioned Tiffany Setting by Tiffany & Co.

Extrabux is an international cashback shopping site, offering up to 30% cashback from 10,000+ Stores!

24S, SSENSE, MATCHESFASHION.COM, Shopbop, NET-A-PORTER, FARFETCH, YOOX, Eastbay, End Clothing, Macys, Neiman Marcus, Saks Fifth Avenue, Saks OFF 5TH, Bergdorf Goodman, Selfridges, Bloomingdales, Coggles, Harrods, Kohl's, Urban Outfitters, ASOS, Missguided, etc.

Join to get $20 welcome bonus now! (How does Welcome Bonus work?)