Perrier vs. San Pellegrino vs. Topo Chico: Which Makes the Best Sparkling Water Brand?

The Difference Between Sparkling Water, Seltzer and Club Soda

• What is Sparkling Water?

Sparkling water is a beverage bottled from a natural source, often a spring. Often, the bubbles in sparkling water are naturally occurring; however, there is some allowance for sparkling water brands to add carbonation. What really sets sparkling water apart from the other types of carbonated water is that it contains natural minerals and salts. According to the FDA, this type of beverage must come from a protected underground water source and contain at least 250 parts per million of minerals. These minerals give sparkling water a subtly tangy flavor, and it can be consumed on its own as a palate refresher.

Sparkling water can also be called mineral water, sparkling mineral water, bubbly water or carbonated water.

• What is Seltzer

Seltzer on the other hand is pure, filtered water with added carbon dioxide to create carbonation. It contains no minerals or salts, and because of this, it doesn’t have any of the acidity often found in sparkling water. Seltzer is a common cocktail ingredient due to the fact that it has very little flavor but adds a nice fizz.

• What is Club Soda?

Club soda is a seltzer with minerals or salts added to mimic the taste of sparkling water. Sometimes called soda water, certain brands of club soda can be quite salty due to the additives. However, it’s popularly drunk on its own, without any flavors or mix-ins. It can also be added to cocktails or substituted in recipes that call for sparkling water.

Best Sparkling Water Brands Buying Guide

• Calorie Count

Water should be water - pure and simple. No calories. No sugar. Just basically a healthy drink. 

But since you like some added flavors and excitement to your beverage, a certain amount of sugar may have been included already. So, when choosing any sparkling water brands, go for those that have “zero added sugar”.

Also, when you cannot skip the sugar, make sure to stick to 5 calories per serving. Consuming too much sparkling water with artificial sweeteners can contribute to weight gain.

• Price

With the amount of water you should be drinking daily, the additional expense of sparkling water can cause a strain on your budget. Find one that suits your budget without compromising quality and taste.

• Ingredients

Check every sparkling water brands’ labels. Look out for red flags in ingredients such as allergen information and dietary restrictions. 

It is also advisable to choose sparkling water that is made or loaded with natural minerals. These can help balance the electrolytes in your body, allowing you to recover faster from thirst and possible dehydration. 

Beware of added citric acid since it can affect the enamel of your teeth.

Perrier vs. San Pellegrino vs. Topo Chico Sparkling Water

Perrier 

Perrier is bottled and sourced in France, which is probably why so people associate the brand with class. The original Perrier is just extra-carbonated mineral water, but it's branched out into canned sparkling waters with added flavors. There's even a version with caffeine to hydrate and perk you up.

Ingredients/Source

The spring from which Perrier water is sourced is naturally carbonated. Both the water and natural carbon dioxide gas are captured independently. The water is then purified, and, during bottling, the carbon dioxide gas is re-added so that the level of carbonation in bottled Perrier matches that of the Vergèze spring.

Perrier Sparkling Water Flavors

• Pink Grapefruit

• Strawberry

• Lime

• Peach

• Watermelon

• L’Orange (Lemon and Orange)

• Lemon

Recommended Taste 

• Perrier Strawberry Flavored Carbonated Mineral Water:Bubbles meet luscious natural flavors in Strawberry-flavored PERRIER® Carbonated Mineral Water. With just a hint of ripe strawberry flavor, it can quench your thirst or cleanse your palate...with zero calories and zero sweeteners.

• Perrier Pink Grapefruit Flavored Carbonated Mineral Water:Pink Grapefruit-flavored PERRIER® Carbonated Mineral Water brings a hint of bracing tartness and an unmistakable tang of refreshness whether you’re at home or on the go. With zero calories and zero sweeteners, it fits your active lifestyle. 

• PERRIER Lemon Flavored Carbonated Mineral Water:Lemon-flavored PERRIER® Carbonated Mineral Water adds a bright tang and a subtly tart twist to the unique mineral water taste. With zero calories and zero sweeteners, its hint of natural citrus flavor comes through. 

Pros 

• Calorie-free

• No sodium content

• Balances stomach acid leaving you feeling full for longer

• Great for cocktails and mocktails

• Comes in a range of fruity and citrus flavors

Cons

• The prickly sensation in the mouth when you drink it may be unpleasant

Why We Think Perrier is Great?

For anyone who loves zero calories and zero sweeteners on their drinks, Perrier Carbonated Mineral Water is for you.

Who Should Buy Perrier?

This sparkling water is for those who are on a low-calorie, low-sodium diet. It is also perfect to use in your cocktails.

How Long does Perrier last?

About 12-18 months.

Where to Buy Perrier ?

Sign up at Extrabux.com！(What is Extrabux) , then you can buy any  Perrier sparkling water  at Amazon, Walmart, Costco, Target, CVS and so on...and you can get up to 4% cashback on your purchase from Extrabux! Sign-Up Bonus: Free to join it & get $20 welcome bonus!

San Pellegrino

In blind taste tests, many people claim to prefer  S.Pellegrino   versus Perrier. The main difference in taste is that San Pellegrino has slightly more fizz than Perrier, which is the main reason people choose to drink sparkling water after all. Bottled at San Pellegrino Terme, Bergamo, Italy, this beverage has been used for years to cleanse palates across Italy and amplify the magnificent flavors of Italian food and wine. As an added bonus, the naturally sparkling water is low in sodium and has zero calories.

Ingredients/Source

S.Pellegrino is a fine quality natural mineral water that flows from natural springs in Val Brembana in the San Pellegrino Terme area, at the foothills of the Italian Alps near Bergamo (Lombardy). S.Pellegrino goes through a 30-year journey inside the earth that mineralizes the water through contact with underground rocks. In the process, it becomes naturally enriched with mineral salts, calcium and magnesium. And with our special addition of carbon dioxide, S.Pellegrino water acquires its bubbles and signature “perlage.” The added CO2 provides the acidity and slightly bitter note. All of this gives S.Pellegrino its unmistakable taste, making it famous throughout the world.

San Pellegrino Sparkling Water Flavors

• Aranciata (Orange)

• Aranciata Rossa (Blood Orange)

• Clementina (Clementine)

• Ficodindia E Arancia (Prickly Pear and Orange)

• Limonata (Lemon)

• Limone E Menta (Lemon and Mint)

• Melograno E Arancia (Pomegranate and Orange)

• Pompelmo (Grapefruit)

Recommended Taste 

• S.Pellegrino’s green glass bottle： with its unique “Vichy” silhouette is an elegant shape shared with its counterpart Acqua Panna. It has always been sophisticated and elegant, traditional yet modern. S.Pellegrino’s premium glass bottles are primarily aimed at the best restaurants, hotels and café around the world.

• S.Pellegrino PET bottles：These conceived to be enjoyed at home and on the go, perfect to refresh and sparkle everywhere. The PET version has been specially researched, created in the same Vichy shape to ensure that the effervescence and perfectly sized bubbles of S.Pellegrino’s unique style and personality would be immediately recognizable.

• S.Pellegrino Magnum Bottom:With its Champagne-like bottom, this 150 cl format is a perfect synthesis of style and taste and well epitomizes the S.Pellegrino sparkling essence, an invitation to experience food as a chance to meet up and share emotions. Magnum is the perfect choice for the most eventful of occasions and it’s available in the most refined restaurants and hotels of the world.

Pros

• Trusted brand since 1899

• Contains electrolytes to maintain hydration

• Perfect on its own or used as a mixer for cocktails

 Cons

• Some clients claimed that their products came in bad packaging

Why We Think S.Pellegrino is Great?

Drinking sparkling mineral water can help you stop craving soda. You will still enjoy the fizz without the extra added sugars in the usual cola. 

Who Should Buy S.Pellegrino?

For those who are in search of the most trusted sparkling water brands, the San Pellegrino sparkling mineral water is an excellent choice. Unlike club soda with added sugars and carbonation, this is the closest best natural alternative you can consume. Adding a squeeze of lemon or lime to a bottle is a good way to add flavor to it.

Where to Buy San Pellegrino？

Sign up at Extrabux.com！(What is Extrabux) , then you can buy any  Perrier sparkling water  at  San Pellegrino, Amazon, Walmart,  Target, CVS and so on...

Which is Healthier Pellegrino or Perrier?

If you like a little more carbonation, then San Pellegrino is your choice. And if you are craving some flavor, Perrier is definitely the more healthy option, while San Pellegrino really shouldn't even be called a flavored sparkling water as it is a sparkling fruit juice.

Topo Chico

Topo Chico Mineral Water has a cult-like following. Just scroll through the reviews, and you’ll find people who swear they only drink Topo Chico having eschewed all other beverages. Many cite the intense bubbles as the main reason behind their addiction, but the iconic, throwback packaging doesn’t hurt either. Topo Chico Mineral Water is bottled from the spring at Cerro del Topo Chico in a tradition that dates back to 1895. This particular order is for several one-and-a-half liter bottles, but this mineral water is also available in individual glass bottles.

Ingredients/Source

Topo Chico is a mineral water that has been sourced and bottled in Monterrey, Mexico, at the Cerro del Topo Chico spring since 1895. Yes, this water has been bottled for the last two centuries. It's naturally carbonated, with just a little extra carbonation added to restore any bubbles lost in the purification process. 

• Sodium: helps avoid dehydration and promotes good bowel function.

• Magnesium: helps in digestion and brain function. It is also calming, which helps sleep.

• Calcium: strengthens bones, works as an astringent and an antacid, regulates heart rate and is important in the transmission of nerve impulses.

• Potassium: involved in the polarization and depolarization of cells. It also helps in the proper functioning of the heart, nervous system, muscles, kidneys and digestion.

• Manganese: stimulates the production of collagen and elastin, which give flexibility, firmness and hydration to the skin. It is an antioxidant, necessary to metabolize proteins and fats and also helps brain functions.

Topo Chico Sparkling Water Flavors

• Grapefruit  

• Lime 

• Original flavors 

Recommended Taste 

• Topo Chico Grapefruit Water：100% Natural sparking mineral water, pure grapefruit is added for a zip of flavor. Refreshing alone or add it to your favorite beverage for a little sparkle.

• Topo Chico Original Mineral Water ：Carbonated fizzy sparkling water. Refreshing and thirst quenching. Sourced from Monerrey, Mexico since 1897. Perfect for when you're thirsty!

• Topo Chico Sparkling Water Lime：Topo Chico Mineral Water Is The Ideal Companion For Any Celebration. Mix With Your Favorite Ingredients And Create New And Refreshing Drinks. 

Pros

• Topo Chico Sparkling Mineral Water has been bottled at the source in Monterrey, Mexico, since 1895.

• Topo Chico is a zero calorie carbonated beverage.

• With several flavors and packages sizes to satisfy even the most legendary thirst. 
  

• No added calories and sodium

Cons

• Its bubbles are less abrasive than most sparkling waters, more like pleasant little pinpricks than relentless fizz. 

• Some customers find it expensive

Why We Think Topo Chico is Great?

With so many flavors to choose from, you will get something that suits your taste. And you’ll never go wrong with the sparkling water as it ranks on the top of Amazon’s bestsellers in grocery & gourmet food, sparkling juice drinks, and tea beverages — these numbers speak for themselves.

Who Should Buy Topo Chico?

For those of you who want to experience the real deal in flavored sparkling water, and want a bottle large enough for 2-3 servings, this is the perfect choice for you.

Where to Buy Topo Chico?

Sign up at Extrabux.com！(What is Extrabux) , then you can buy any Topo Chico sparkling water  at  Topo Chico, Amazon, Walmart,  Target and so on...

Summarize

• Perrier was tasteless with big bubbles that faded quickly. There was no hint of mineral and it was considered classic sparkling water

• San Pellegrino had some tiny bubbles with a hint of mineral. It didn’t linger but faded so it was easier to drink more of.  This water goes well with cheeses, meats, and fish. It isn’t over powering but you know it’s there.

• Topo Chico was crisp and clean, nice bubbles and a good balance of mineral. We all really loved this one and it was one of our favorites. It did extremely well when compared to the Gerolsteiner.

Sparkling Water vs. Club Soda vs. Seltzer vs. Tonic

Are sparkling water, seltzer, and club soda really all the same thing?Yes, seltzer and sparkling water are essentially the same thing; just plain old water that’s carbonated (a.k.a. made bubbly) with carbon dioxide. Sparkling mineral water, meanwhile, is slightly different. In this case, you're sipping water from natural springs or wells that contains minerals like sodium and magnesium and is naturally carbonated. Club soda, on the other hand, is plain water that has both minerals and carbon added to it in processing.

Potential Risks of Sparkling Water

If you don’t like plain water, sparkling water is a good alternative to sugary sodas and fruit juices. The healthiest type of sparkling water is unflavored and unsweetened.

Watch out for products that include additives or sweeteners. These types of sparkling water can cause side effects for some people: 

• Tooth Decay

Sparkling waters that are high in sugar can cause tooth decay. But plain sparkling water has minimal effects on your teeth, especially compared to drinking soda. You can further prevent tooth decay by maintaining a good oral hygiene routine and by alternating sparkling water with plain water to cleanse your enamel. 

• Gas and Bloating

The carbonation in sparkling water causes some people to experience gas and bloating. If you notice excessive gas while drinking sparkling water, your best bet is to switch to plain water. 

Sparkling Water Brand FAQ

1. Is Sparkling Water Bad for You?

Sparkling water, without added sugars, is still water. It quenches your thirst and hydrates your body. However, because of the addition of carbonation, it can leave you feeling bloated. If you are a bit hesitant about which to choose, go for seltzer water instead since it is the healthier option. 

Over consumption of sparkling water can lead to irritated bowel syndrome (IBS), so it is best to regulate the amount of sparkling water taken per day. 

2. Which is Healthier: Soda Water or Sparkling Water?

As mentioned earlier, soda water is not a gray category for water. But for most people, soda water means seltzer water, especially if it is from a soda maker. Both are considered healthy beverages. 

However, since seltzer is just water with carbonation, it is healthier compared to sparkling water which may contain some added sweeteners and flavorings.

3. Is Sparkling Water Bad for Your Kidneys?

When consumed in moderation, sparkling water is good for your kidneys since it leads you to get rid of toxins in the body. 

4.What Are the Different Types of Sparkling Water?

Sparkling water, club soda, soda water, seltzer water - what is the difference between these? Although each type of sparkling water has its unique element, one thing they all share is the presence of carbonation.

Sparkling water is just water with added carbonation and sometimes, flavorings. Club soda, on the one hand, has added salts to neutralize the acidity of the added carbonation. 

Soda water is a gray term in water verbiage and can mean differently from one person to another. It can mean club soda or seltzer water, depending on what the person believes. Seltzer water is just water with added carbonation, so the product of a soda maker is technically seltzer water.

10 Spiciest Instant Ramen Noodles in the World 2024 (Samyang, Mamee, Paldo, NongShim)

10 Best Instant Coffees with Creamer And/No Sugar for Backpacking

10 Best Mini Non-Alcoholic Sparkling Wines to Drink Anytime

12 Best Dairy Free Vegan Substitute for Heavy Cream in Pasta, Soup and Baking

12 Best Tasting Beers that Don't Taste Like Beer for Non Beer Drinkers

Extrabux is an international cashback shopping site, offering up to 30% cashback from 10,000+ Stores!

Squarespace, SkinStore, MATCHESFASHION, The Wall Street Journal, NordVPN, Visible, Armani Exchange, Sam's Club, PUMA, AliExpress, Card Cash, NET-A-PORTER, Udacity, Udemy, Selfridges, LOOKFANTASTIC, Vimeo, Coach Outlet, lululemon, PrettyLittleThing, Booking.com, Ripley's Aquarium, iHerb, Groupon, etc.

Join to get $20 welcome bonus now! (How does Welcome Bonus work?)