Simply Orange vs. Tropicana vs. Florida's Natural vs. Minute Maid Orange Juice: Which is Best?

What are the most popular orange juice brands?

The following are the 4 most popular orange juice brands:

#1. Tropicana: 

With a long and storied history since its founding in 1947 by Anthony Rossi, Tropicana has played a significant role in the orange juice industry. Its development of the flash pasteurization process in 1952 was a major innovation that helped in preserving the quality of orange juice. Now under the umbrella of PepsiCo, it has maintained its status as a leading refrigerated orange juice brand not just in the US but globally. Its well-known products include Tropicana Pure Premium® Original No Pulp Orange Juice and Some Pulp Orange Juice.

Tropicana Pure Premium® Original (No Pulp)

($3, was $3.99 FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($3.96, 46 Fl oz Bottle FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

#2. Simply Orange: 

Launched in 2001 and part of the Coca-Cola Company, Simply Orange has quickly gained popularity due to its commitment to using only 100% fruit extracts and producing not-from-concentrate orange juice. It focuses on providing a pure and natural product without any artificial flavors or additives, which aligns well with the growing consumer preference for clean-label beverages. Its well-known orange juice products include Simply Orange Pulp Free and Simply Orange High Pulp.

Simply Orange Pulp Free

($4.49 FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($4.48, 52 Fl oz Bottle FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

#3. Minute Maid: 

Formulated in 1945 by the Florida Foods Corporation, it was the first frozen concentrated orange juice on the market. In 1960, it was acquired by the Coca-Cola Company and now offers various orange juice lines, such as original, pulp-free, and those fortified with zinc, vitamin C, D, and calcium.

Minute Maid Premium Original Orange Juice

($3.99 FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($3.96, 59 Fl oz Bottle FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

#4. Florida’s Natural:

Florida’s Natural: Starting as a group of independent farmers in 1987, it sources its oranges from its own groves and uses the marketing strategy of “we own the land, we own the trees, we own the company.” They can ensure the use of high-quality oranges in their juices. It offers no-pulp, with-pulp, and fortified orange juice varieties containing calcium and vitamin D.

Florida's Natural Orange Juice with Pulp

($3.98, 52 Fl oz Bottle FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

So, how do you choose between these orange juice brands? We compare their popular orange juice products to provide you with the most comprehensive review so that you can refer to them when buying.

A quick look at the differences between 4 well-known orange juice drinks

To compare these brands, we chose one of their representative flavors. Let's analyze each aspect to see which brand may dominate.

Editor's review: Simply Orange vs. Tropicana vs. Florida's Natural vs. Minute Maid: Which one is best?

My number one choice is Tropicana!

($3, was $3.99 FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($3.96, 46 Fl oz Bottle FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

❤️ I have to say that Tropicana Pure Premium® Original No Pulp orange juice has truly won my heart.

First and foremost, the taste is an absolute delight. It has this rich and mellow flavor that is so pure and intense. It's like a burst of sunshine in a glass. The absence of pulp gives it a smooth and creamy texture that just glides over the palate, making it a luxurious drinking experience. The sweetness and acidity are in perfect harmony, creating a balance that is both refreshing and satisfying. It really does remind me of freshly squeezed orange juice, but with the added convenience of being readily available.

The quality of the product is also a major factor in my preference. It's made from 100% pure orange juice, straight from fresh-picked oranges and never from concentrate. There are no added sugars, water, or preservatives, which gives me peace of mind knowing that I'm consuming something natural and healthy. And being non-GMO project verified is just an added bonus.

I also appreciate the brand's reputation. Tropicana has been a household name for decades and has clearly earned its #1 ranking in the orange juice category. Their extensive marketing campaigns have made it a familiar and trusted choice, and the wide range of bottle sizes means I can always get the amount that suits my needs, whether it's for a single serving or for the whole family.

Sure, it might be a bit pricier than some other options out there, but for me, the overall experience and quality make it well worth the investment. Every sip is a reminder of why this orange juice stands out from the rest and has become my firm favorite.

Money Saving Tips First:

In fact, you can save up to 100% on online shopping at home and abroad! 

Such a high amount of cash back comes from Extrabux (What is Extrabux?), it also offers coupon codes and recent promotions, and brings together 10,000+ sites (US, China, UK, Japan, Australia , Germany, France, Italy, etc.).

Just sign up for an Extrabux account and earn exciting cash back every time you place an order via the relevant link. Sign-Up Bonus: Join for FREE & Earn $20 Welcome Bonus today! Then earn $5 Friend Referral Bonus!

Whether you are buying cheap domestic products, international luxury goods, or buying mobile phones, computers, refrigerators, washing machines, clothes, shoes, bags, mother and baby products, snacks, drinks, or booking air tickets, hotels, car rentals, or registering services and memberships , you can save money on all related purchases - save $1,000 a year!

MORE FROM

Top 10 Strongest Mints in the World 2025

Love the taste of mint? Here are some...

46187

Details

Real Reviews and Comparisons of the Best Orange Juice Drinks

#1. Taste: 

Tropicana Pure Premium® Original No Pulp presents a rich and bold flavor, a pure orange essence with a perfect harmony of sweet and tangy notes. Its smooth, creamy texture, sans pulp, makes it a favorite among those seeking a refined and classic OJ experience.

Simply Orange Pulp Free focuses on a clean, light, and refreshing taste. With a more delicate sweetness, it offers a subtle and natural flavor, ideal for those who prefer a less intense citrus hit and a smooth, pulp-free consistency.

Minute Maid Original brings a familiar and reliable flavor, a balanced blend of sweet and tart that has been a staple for many. It may not be as bold as Tropicana but offers a mellow and approachable taste, suitable for a wide range of palates.

Florida's Natural with Pulp stands out with its rustic and earthy flavor. The pulp adds an extra dimension, releasing additional flavor as you chew. It has a stronger orange essence, with a higher acidity level that gives it a more pronounced citrusy kick, perfect for pulp lovers and those desiring a more intense OJ adventure.

#2. Quality: 

Tropicana Pure Premium® Original No Pulp prides itself on using 100% pure orange juice from fresh-picked oranges, never from concentrate. It has no added sugars, water, or preservatives and is non-GMO project verified. Renowned for its freshness and quality, Tropicana has a long-established brand reputation and a top ranking in the orange juice category.

Simply Orange Pulp Free also features 100% pure orange juice, not from concentrate, crafted from real, ripe oranges. It is pasteurized for safety, non-GMO verified, and offers a clean and natural product. With its "fresh taste guarantee," it has built a solid brand image, especially among those valuing simplicity and purity.

Minute Maid Original contains 100% pure orange juice, though not as explicit about being never from concentrate. It is a well-known and trusted brand, offering consistent quality and wide availability. It provides a good balance of taste and nutrition, making it a popular choice for families.

Florida's Natural with Pulp is made from Florida-grown oranges, known for their quality and flavor. It contains pulp, which not only adds texture but also indicates a closer resemblance to freshly squeezed juice. The brand emphasizes its use of natural ingredients and has a strong regional identity, appealing to consumers seeking a more artisanal and natural product.

#3. Nutritional Value: 

Tropicana Pure Premium® Original No Pulp leads in vitamin C content, with a 240g serving providing 125.3mg (139% of the daily value). It also contains potassium and B vitamins, offering a good nutritional profile.

Simply Orange Pulp Free provides 34mg of vitamin C per cup (38% DV), along with potassium and some calcium, presenting a balanced nutrient offering with a relatively lower calorie and sugar content compared to some others.

Minute Maid Original contains 72mg of vitamin C per 8 fl oz serving (80% DV) and is rich in potassium. It also offers some calcium and may be fortified with other vitamins and minerals depending on the formulation.

Florida's Natural with Pulp contains a decent amount of vitamin C and the pulp provides dietary fiber, beneficial for digestive health, along with potassium and other nutrients.

#4. Price: 

Tropicana Pure Premium® Original No Pulp prices range from about 6.1¢ to 8.0¢ per fl. oz, depending on the size. While it offers quality and taste, it is on the moderately priced side.

Simply Orange Pulp Free is generally around 6.7¢ to 10.8¢ per fl. oz. It emphasizes taste and quality but may be a bit pricier per ounce.

Minute Maid Original has a 59 fl. oz carton at around 5.4¢ per fl. oz, with canned options varying. It offers a range of prices to fit different budgets, with the carton being a more economical choice.

Florida's Natural with Pulp is priced at about 5.7¢ to 6.0¢ per fl. oz, offering a relatively lower price point, especially for the 52 oz size, providing a good balance between price and quality.

#5. Packaging: 

Tropicana comes in various plastic bottle sizes, with an attractive label and a screw cap for reliable sealing and freshness preservation.

Simply Orange has plastic bottles in different sizes, with an elegant and simple label design, made of sturdy plastic that is recyclable.

Minute Maid offers cartons and cans. The 59 fl. oz cartons are lightweight and easy to open and pour from, while the 12 fl. oz cans are durable and convenient for single servings, with the frozen concentrate option providing an economical alternative.

Florida's Natural with Pulp has a 52 oz carton and an 89 oz plastic jug. The carton is compact and recyclable, and the jug is sturdy with a handle, both designed to keep the juice fresh and prevent leaks, with a rustic label design.

#6. User Reviews and Ratings:

►    

Tropicana Pure Premium® Original No Pulp has high ratings, with consumers loving its taste and quality but sometimes noting the higher price.

⭐How about trying and experiencing it?

Review 1:
I've been a loyal Tropicana fan for years. This original no pulp version is just amazing. It has a rich and intense orange flavor that really wakes me up in the morning. The fact that it's not from concentrate makes it feel like I'm getting the purest form of orange goodness. It's a bit pricey compared to some other brands, but I think it's worth every penny for the quality. I always stock up when it's on sale.

Review 2:
Tropicana Pure Premium Original No Pulp is my go-to orange juice. The taste is consistently delicious. It has a perfect balance of sweetness and acidity. I love that it has no pulp, so it's really smooth going down. It's also great for making cocktails. I've used it in mimosas and screwdrivers, and it really elevates the drink. I highly recommend it to anyone who wants a high-quality orange juice.

Review 3:
This orange juice is top-notch. The packaging is also nice and easy to handle. I appreciate that it's non-GMO and has a good amount of vitamin C. It tastes so fresh, even though it's been through the bottling process. I sometimes drink it straight, and other times I use it in smoothies. It blends really well and gives a great citrusy flavor boost. I can't imagine starting my day without it.

Review 4:
I bought Tropicana Pure Premium Original No Pulp after hearing good things about it. I was not disappointed. The flavor is so natural and pure. It's like squeezing oranges right in my kitchen. I like that it's available in different sizes, so I can get a small one for when I'm on the go or a large one for the family. It's become a staple in our fridge, and my kids love it too.

►    

Simply Orange Pulp Free also has great ratings, though a few found issues with its flavor or price.

⭐How about trying and experiencing it?

Review 1:
Simply Orange Pulp Free is a great option for those who want a clean and simple orange juice. The taste is very refreshing and light. It doesn't have that overly sweet or artificial taste that some other juices have. I like to drink it with my breakfast, and it pairs well with toast and eggs. The bottle is easy to pour from, and the label is simple and easy to read. I'll definitely be buying this again.

Review 2:
I switched to Simply Orange Pulp Free recently, and I'm really glad I did. It has a really nice, natural orange flavor. It's not too thick or too thin, just the right consistency. I like that it's made from real oranges and nothing else. It's also a good source of vitamin C. I've noticed that it stays fresh for a decent amount of time in the fridge. It's a great addition to my daily routine.

Review 3:
This orange juice is delicious. It has a smooth texture and a mild, pleasant taste. I find it very easy to drink, even when I'm not in the mood for something too strong. I like that it comes in a convenient size for single servings. I often take it to work with me and drink it during my break. It gives me a little boost of energy and satisfies my thirst. I would recommend it to anyone who likes a simple and pure orange juice.

Review 4:
Simply Orange Pulp Free is a winner in my book. The taste is so good that it makes me feel like I'm getting a healthy treat. I like that it's not overly processed and doesn't have any added sugars or preservatives. It's perfect for making popsicles too. I just pour it into molds and freeze it, and it makes a delicious and healthy summer snack. I'm very happy with this purchase and will continue to buy it.

►    

Minute Maid Original is well-liked for its classic flavor and availability, but some feel it lacks intensity or is a bit watery.

⭐How about trying and experiencing it?

Review 1:
Minute Maid Original has been a family favorite for a long time. It has a familiar and comforting taste. It's not too tangy or too sweet, just right for everyone in the family. We usually buy the big carton, and it lasts us a while. It's also a good value for the money. I like that it's 100% pure orange juice. It's great for making orange juice ice cubes too. We use them in smoothies and it gives a nice orange flavor boost.

Review 2:
I grew up drinking Minute Maid Original, and it still holds a special place in my heart. The taste is consistent, and it's available everywhere. I like that it comes in different packaging options, like cans and cartons. The cans are great for picnics and on-the-go. The juice itself is refreshing and quenches my thirst well. I don't mind that it's not as fancy as some other brands. It gets the job done and tastes good.

Review 3:
This orange juice is a reliable choice. It has a decent amount of vitamin C, which is important for me and my family. The flavor is okay, not the most amazing I've ever had, but it's good enough for everyday drinking. I like that it's easy to find in the grocery store. Sometimes I mix it with a little bit of sparkling water to make a fizzy orange drink. It's a nice variation. I'll keep buying it as long as it stays affordable.

Review 4:
Minute Maid Original is what I reach for when I want a simple and straightforward orange juice. It's not overly complex in flavor, but it has a nice citrusy taste. I like that it's made from oranges and doesn't have any added colors or flavors. The carton is easy to store in the fridge, and it pours well. I've used it in baking too, like in orange cakes, and it gives a nice flavor. It's a versatile and dependable product.

►    

Florida's Natural with Pulp has mixed reviews. Some enjoy its natural feel and pulp, while others dislike the sweet aftertaste and inconsistent pulp distribution.

⭐How about trying and experiencing it?

Review 1:
I love Florida's Natural with Pulp. The pulp gives it a really authentic and rustic feel. It's like drinking freshly squeezed oranges with all the bits and pieces. The flavor is strong and tangy, which I really like. It makes me feel like I'm getting the full experience of an orange. The packaging is nice too, and it's clear that it's made from good quality Florida oranges. I highly recommend it to pulp lovers.

Review 2:
This orange juice is amazing. The pulp adds so much texture and flavor. It has a natural sweetness that is just right. I like to drink it slowly and savor the taste. It's also great for making orange marmalade. I've made it a few times using this juice, and it turns out delicious. The bottle is sturdy and the label is informative. I'm a big fan and will keep buying it.

Review 3:
Florida's Natural with Pulp is a treat for the taste buds. The pulp gives it a unique character that sets it apart from other orange juices. I find it very refreshing and satisfying. It's a little pricier than some other options, but I think it's worth it for the quality and taste. I like to have it with my brunch on weekends. It pairs well with pancakes and bacon. It's a great addition to any meal.

Review 4:
I was hesitant to try this because of the pulp, but I'm so glad I did. The pulp actually makes it more enjoyable for me. It has a bold orange flavor that is really delicious. I like that it's made from natural ingredients and has no added sugars. The juice stays fresh in the fridge, and I like to shake it well before pouring to make sure the pulp is evenly distributed. It's a great orange juice, and I'll be sticking with it.

Conclusion

In the end, the decision among these orange juices depends on your personal preferences. If you seek a strong, pure flavor without pulp and are willing to invest a bit more, Tropicana might be your ideal pick. For a light and refined taste, Simply Orange could be the top choice. Minute Maid offers a reliable and affordable option with a traditional flavor. And if you relish a more rustic and textured experience, Florida's Natural with Pulp is worth considering. Each brand has its own unique qualities, and no matter which one you choose, you can enjoy the delicious and nutritious goodness of orange juice. So, the next time you stroll down the grocery aisle, let your taste buds and lifestyle guide you to the perfect orange juice companion.

My number one choice is Tropicana!

($3, was $3.99 FROM Kroger  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

($3.96, 46 Fl oz Bottle FROM Walmart  - Get Up To 4% Cash Back)

❤️ Tropicana Pure Premium® Original No Pulp orange juice has truly won my heart.

More：

Extrabux is an international cashback shopping site, offering up to 30% cashback from 10,000+ Stores!

Squarespace, SkinStore, MATCHESFASHION, The Wall Street Journal, NordVPN, Visible, Armani Exchange, Sam's Club, PUMA, AliExpress, Card Cash, NET-A-PORTER, Udacity, Udemy, Selfridges, LOOKFANTASTIC, Vimeo, Coach Outlet, lululemon, PrettyLittleThing, Booking.com, Ripley's Aquarium, iHerb, Groupon, etc.

Join to get $20 welcome bonus now! (How does Welcome Bonus work?)